Hi Aquabox, could you please clear some points up for me. I include below your original list of calculations re resources for Wild Collection V Aquaculture.
Okay so let’s look at what it takes to net collect a fish off of the reef:
- A tank of gas to fuel up the boat to go collecting.
- Dive and fish collection gear to use once at the reef.
- A temporary holding facility where ideally animals are held for at least a couple weeks prior to shipping.
- Fish shipping materials: styrofoam and cardboard box, bags, heat/cold packs.
- Fuel for the plane to ship the fish.
Now let’s look at what it takes to breed fishes inland:
- All of the above to source brood-stock.
- A facility to house brood-stock and rear live foods, larvae, and young fishes.
- Equipment to do all of the above (tanks, sumps, filter media, skimmers, salt, RO/DI, lights, etc.).
- Staff to do all of the above (they drive to and from work everyday consuming fuel and more).
- Utilities to keep the facility running (electricity, gas, water, sewage).
- Months upon months of work to bring fishes up to sellable size (which oftentimes are still tiny).
- Fish shipping materials: styrofoam and cardboard box, bags, heat/cold packs.
Hi again. First I must apologize if I have missed something here.
You list what it takes for wild collection, but you seem to stop at the arrival airport?
Then the way it reads to me, you seem to list a whole lot of additional resources that aquaculture requires, but make no mention that, what I would imagine, Wild caught animals also require
2. Transport and processing through the airport to the wholesale facility of wild caught specimans
3. A facility to hold all the wild caught animals.
4 .Equipment to hold all the wild caught animals for conditioning due to their long journey. Tanks, Sumps etc, unpacking and disposal of original packaging. Chemical treatment if required.
5 Staff to work at the wholesalers of wild collected animals and their travel to and from work.
6 Utilities to run the wholesalers building to store the wild caught animals. Gas Electricity etc.
7 Wild caught fish shipping materials, styrofoam, boxes etc.
Once again I apologize if I am missing something here, I keep reading the sentences over and over, but it always seems that you are suggesting these additional resources are only relevant to aquaculture.
One more point is you seem to me to equate the first lot of resources to both aquaculture and Wild collection. How many animals do you estimate are required as brood stock for aquaculture and how regularly must they be replaced with more wild brood stock. Surely the amount of energy used to constantly collect and transport all those wild collected fish is extremely higher than the occasional collection for aquaculture. The smaller number of animals compared as a percentage of payload on the transport surely should be reflected proportionally. The less animals on the plane the less of the total percentage of fuel should be levied to their use.
I really appreciate your expertise, as I must admit I am just a simple hobbyist. I have no scientific background or any experiance in the calculation of resources. I understand your support for both Wild Collected and aquacultured animals, but to me even without the numbers the comparison seems confusing.
I will probably regret asking these questions as it won`t` be the first time some one points out the obvious to me, ha ha. However I am to long in the tooth to be afraid to ask questions about something I don`t` understand.
Thanks in advance for any reply to my questions. Best wishes Tony Thompson.[/QUOTE]