Do you Coral QT

In what way are you curious? You just treat it like a normal reef tank in terms of water quality.

Regarding parameters, how often you test, dosing, etc. Basically gauging how much time/effort people put into their qt tanks.

The people who responded gave me the answers I was looking for, so I’m good.
 
In what way are you curious? You just treat it like a normal reef tank in terms of water quality.
Of course, I’m speaking on those who only dip, and add into their DT. There’s has to be a reason others never run into issues while others do
 
Of course, I’m speaking on those who only dip, and add into their DT. There’s has to be a reason others never run into issues while others do


It can also be that others don't notice the pests. It really is a crapshoot. Some people just get lucky. Some people have tons of predators that would eat the pests (copperband butterflies, lots of wrasses, scooters/mandarins, etc.) so the numbers never get too noticeable
 
Yes I do now. Normally for about a minimum of 30 days; screening for pests, nuisance algaes, etc. I also find it helpful to remove as much of the original tile/ rock/ mount etc. for This is also gives me a great opportunity to condition the new coral and makes extra spot feeding easier to help “bulk them up”. I try to maintain my QT tank at similar parameters to my display, which is a bit easier with primarily soft corals, but I still do weekly testing and water changes along with whatever dosing is needed.
It’s really surprising what can pop up after just a few weeks, aiptaisia especially. I noticed one pop up on the underside of one of my recent Reef a palooza frags. Only noticed because I was diligent in cleaning the acrylic that day so had a clear view underneath the frag rack, also why I’m more diligent now about removing original mounts.
I’ve dealt with just about any pest you can name in the past and they all are a pain and can be devastating once they enter a system. Granted I was dealing with a lot of wild import corals at the time, but the main pests still persist in the hobby: aiptaisia, coral eating nudibranchs, flatworms to name a few. Many these pests eggs can survive a dip, and so can hidden aiptaisia.
One of my buddies recently got a tank raised green star frag and I was over checking out his tank and I noticed a tiny little nudibranch with bright green star colored frills on its back. Now I know some reefers might pay for this “pest” in particular as a green star control, but that’s a different story haha. It still was able to enter his tank after dipping and show up a few weeks later.
 
It can also be that others don't notice the pests. It really is a crapshoot. Some people just get lucky. Some people have tons of predators that would eat the pests (copperband butterflies, lots of wrasses, scooters/mandarins, etc.) so the numbers never get too noticeable
Yes this, I think many people don’t realize they might have a pest issue. Also with the right predators they may never get to a noticeable outbreak. Some people just get lucky, but that’s a small percentage, and lowers over time.
 
I didn’t properly QT my acropora, so now I’m battling parasitic flatworms.

Now I removed all the acros from the display, and I’m doing the full QT on them.

It’s definitely partly based on luck, but there are obviously red flags you should avoid to increase your chances of success: buying a lot of mariculture acros without QT is a one way ticket to flatworm station. lol
 
Yes I do now. Normally for about a minimum of 30 days; screening for pests, nuisance algaes, etc. I also find it helpful to remove as much of the original tile/ rock/ mount etc. for This is also gives me a great opportunity to condition the new coral and makes extra spot feeding easier to help “bulk them up”. I try to maintain my QT tank at similar parameters to my display, which is a bit easier with primarily soft corals, but I still do weekly testing and water changes along with whatever dosing is needed.
It’s really surprising what can pop up after just a few weeks, aiptaisia especially. I noticed one pop up on the underside of one of my recent Reef a palooza frags. Only noticed because I was diligent in cleaning the acrylic that day so had a clear view underneath the frag rack, also why I’m more diligent now about removing original mounts.
I’ve dealt with just about any pest you can name in the past and they all are a pain and can be devastating once they enter a system. Granted I was dealing with a lot of wild import corals at the time, but the main pests still persist in the hobby: aiptaisia, coral eating nudibranchs, flatworms to name a few. Many these pests eggs can survive a dip, and so can hidden aiptaisia.
One of my buddies recently got a tank raised green star frag and I was over checking out his tank and I noticed a tiny little nudibranch with bright green star colored frills on its back. Now I know some reefers might pay for this “pest” in particular as a green star control, but that’s a different story haha. It still was able to enter his tank after dipping and show up a few weeks later.
Removing the plugs gets rid of a lot of problems, the majority I would say. There are reefers with astonishing tanks that claim to never QT coral and honestly, it surprises me.

Like you all mentioned, maybe they have their issues, but from what can be seen, their tanks are not wiped out like many claim, but looks amazing

PS my previous nano got wiped by bryopsis
 
I didn’t properly QT my acropora, so now I’m battling parasitic flatworms.

Now I removed all the acros from the display, and I’m doing the full QT on them.

It’s definitely partly based on luck, but there are obviously red flags you should avoid to increase your chances of success: buying a lot of mariculture acros without QT is a one way ticket to flatworm station. lol
Aquaculture is becoming popular now adays, less risk but still risk involved
 
Knowing that eggs will hatch a few days after DIP, do any of you DIP again? If so, how many days later? And how many times?
Eggs as in pest on coral correct ?

This is a good question, I’m curious if different pest have different hatch time frames
 
Knowing that eggs will hatch a few days after DIP, do any of you DIP again? If so, how many days later? And how many times?

I just watch out and re-dip if I see them. My corals that go through QT get dipped at the end as well as the beginning. It is important to keep the QT bare for this reason as it makes it much easier to spot any flatworms and such.
 
I am still fairly new to the hobby, I have QT coral but on my new build I won’t be

My regimen will consist of placing coral on a rack in the DT, dipping before intro to tank and inspection (with magnifier + dental tools to pick off any unwanted pest ln coral base + hydrogen peroxide dip for algae)

I’ll then closely inspect my coral for any signs of pest and if any signs are shown I’ll re dip as necessary

Could leave the coral on a frag rack for a while to inspect
 
I just watch out and re-dip if I see them. My corals that go through QT get dipped at the end as well as the beginning. It is important to keep the QT bare for this reason as it makes it much easier to spot any flatworms and such.
Do you use dips from different companies?
 

Attachments

  • Capture d’écran, le 2023-09-24 à 18.08.32.png
    Capture d’écran, le 2023-09-24 à 18.08.32.png
    532.9 KB · Views: 32

IF YOU HAD TO TAKE A REEFING EXAM, WOULD YOU PASS?

  • Yes!

    Votes: 32 45.7%
  • Not yet, but I have one that I want to buy in mind!

    Votes: 9 12.9%
  • No.

    Votes: 26 37.1%
  • Other (please explain).

    Votes: 3 4.3%
Back
Top