Effects of tap water on Nitrifying during Rip-Clean method: Experiment

all you’d have to do Coxey is set cured rocks in the fail water, and post the 24 hours results. We will never know if that reported test comes from blank water, or the actual tank for example, but it would show creativity and true intent to validate the original test if you did that/thought of that quick easy step on your own when designing the test originally. Me having to think of protection steps doesn’t make me believe much in any of the 2.0 steps but I’ll take what I can get. The first arrangement was totally biased unfairly.

simply set in cured rocks to cure the fail water, post those readings next day. Easy.
 
all you’d have to do Coxey is set cured rocks in the fail water, and post the 24 hours results. We will never know if that reported test comes from blank water, or the actual tank for example, but it would show creativity and true intent to validate the original test if you did that/thought of that quick easy step on your own when designing the test originally. Me having to think of protection steps doesn’t make me believe much in any of the 2.0 steps but I’ll take what I can get. The first arrangement was totally biased unfairly.

simply set in cured rocks to cure the fail water, post those readings next day. Easy.
No clue what you'r talking about. What is the 'fail water'?
 
Are you wondering because of the need for PO4 for multiplication of nitrifiers? or why? I guess I can see the reason for constant PO4 readings - not sure about Nitrate or 30 day period? @Lasse?
IMO for clear results we need a environment that will mimic all of our tanks. I believe if this is made in a rush is set to fail. This test is only banking on ammonia as a food source to the bacteria. If the reading of po4 and no3 are zero is a big variable to not be taken into account don’t you think?

edit: for anyone that been in the hobby long enough can tell the colour of mature rock and new rock. The rock in this test doesn’t look mature, looks fresh from the shelf to me. The pic on the scales rock locks bone dry to!
 
Last edited:
IMO for clear results we need a environment that will mimic all of our tanks. I believe if this is made in a rush is set to fail. This test is only banking on ammonia as a food source to the bacteria. If the reading of po4 and no3 are zero is a big variable to not be taken into account don’t you think?
My tap water has lots of both of them tbh
 
Far from it. I’m sure the OP will have both tests and will oblige.
Can he explain also why his 6months rock looks new and dry on the scales pic? I would appreciate. Lost the excitement in this thread already. This is embarrassing!
If the goal was to have a go at Brandon you all should of chosen a different way this is really sad!
 
Im not sure what Brandon meant with his test - and I'm not sure what the purpose would be to do it with new rock meant. BUT - I do think that you should think about this.

Lets say in Step 1, you have 2 ppm Ammonia at the beginning and the next day you have 1ppm and the next day you have .5. I would repeat step 1. until you get a constant reliable time where the ammonia drops to zero. Note this ONLY becomes an issue IF it takes longer than 1 day to complete Step 1. If you don't understand what I'm talking about - you can PM me.


Agreed, and I understand.. I'll consider that tonight and tomorrow and go from there after tests tomorrow afternoon. Hopefully the tank has processed the ammonia by tomorrow.

Like I said, I would love to do a long and lengthy drawn out test on this. Maybe it will encourage someone else to do so.

It's just gonna have to go along with the spare time I have to perform the tests.

I wanted this test to be for the general individual to begin with. Instant Fishless cycle using Dr. Tim's instructions with rocks that should have accumulated the bacteria needed to process the amonia and using a test kit that is affordable and readily available to the home aquarist.

Then repeat it after washing rocks with tap water to simulate a rip-clean.

If the average home aquarist can not perform this and get readings that suggest it ok to do so with the test kits they have available then it probably shouldn't be done IMO.
 
Thank you for the clarification, it concern me that you mentioned on opening statement that a QT was being used for this process.
Regarding your second test can I clarify if no3 and po4 detectable readings will be present for more than 30 days will be taken in to account? For a real life comparison, Or is this going to be done immediately on the next 72hours?
Are you using a second tank as a control?


This will be over the next 72 hours. Possibly week if thr tank hasn't processed the ammonia by tomorrow or the next day.

No, I do not have a second tank as a control. What exactly are you wanting to see from the control.

It will be proven the tank can process the ammonia before the rocks are rinsed. That kinda of is the control... proving that the bacteria is present first before proceeding to the second part of the test.
 
Last edited:
Can he explain also why his 6months rock looks new and dry on the scales pic? I would appreciate. Lost the excitement in this thread already. This is embarrassing!
If the goal was to have a go at Brandon you all should of chosen a different way this is really sad!


Most of it has been in my sump with no lights. One piece came from the the DT a while back and has some faded green corraline. It was dry rock to begin with... there are some pineapple sponges on it.
 
Can he explain also why his 6months rock looks new and dry on the scales pic? I would appreciate. Lost the excitement in this thread already. This is embarrassing!
If the goal was to have a go at Brandon you all should of chosen a different way this is really sad!


This was actually to attempt to prove Brandon is correct, fwiw.
 
This was actually to attempt to prove Brandon is correct, fwiw.
Please don’t insult me. I can’t see any reliable test coming out of this thread. Even if you prove Brandon right
 
Please don’t insult me. I can’t see any reliable test coming out of this thread. Even if you prove Brandon right
I’m sure any other advice you can offer to improve the process would be considered.
 
this thread is the official convention of people who have no work threads, literally if we added up all the remote tanks worked here from the crew and kept for inspection the sum would be zero.

what's handy is that we still do full rip cleans of every system that presents, more new outcomes are coming from private message jobs, our methods move other people's reef animals state to state without loss and log the patterns, and those results have no bearing on your results because this test is aligned oppositely of what we do in every way. there's not even any proof those were cycled rocks above, you can arrange anything you want here and state a reading from anywhere.

using other people's tanks is a handy way to streamline what's reported, as accurate, as true and repeatable.

Lasse, this is the kind of effort I need from you vs coat tailing

Coxey at least appears to have set up an experiment even if it has no bearing on rip cleans at all. That degree of rock matches no cull, no starting arrangement Coxey can find from any working rip clean example. everything is aligned here to fail, and those who do not save other's reef animals are aligned to click like, in step.
after this misaligned test is complete, nobody here is going to begin a rinseless tank transfer thread so how does this post help anyone? those who don't assertively take on build jobs live time aren't going to all of a sudden become assertive, they're still evaluating far from the sidelines.

lets say (surprisingly) this test deems the nitrification to be totally killed

how do you apply that to the constant stream of move jobs and tank upgrades needed? there will be silence, gaps where nobody actually does any work with the findings

and filling those gaps for inspection...rip cleaning.

this thread means something only if someone invents a better way to handle tank moves, upgrades and invasion fixes all by no rinsing, or rinsing a different way other than tap (and still getting the cleanliness required for fifty pages of skip cycles with no bottle bac added)

if someone tries to imply the inverse of this test to real world jobs, I'll sub to that to see how that turns out.
Geez Louise.... why are you so angry? We get it, you put good work into it, and value your opinion. But honestly you sound like you are the self identified one and all reef savior. It's really a bit much....no candy for you tonight or something? All the houses ran out? Man alive....
 
Nice late show up lol this is sixth inning

Im never on time either

my method was being challenged in a wild manner by someone I recently saved their whole setup using similar methods. It was a special burn among ‘em

One day you’ll have a method too, but instead of trying to wreck it I’ll support it if it makes sense.
 
Last edited:
Nice late show up lol this is sixth inning

Im never on time either

my method was being challenged in a wild manner to someone I recent saved their whole setup. One day you’ll have a method too, but instead of trying to wreck it I’ll support it if it makes sense.
I was waiting for you to calm down.... I've been following no worries...
 
Can he explain also why his 6months rock looks new and dry on the scales pic? I would appreciate. Lost the excitement in this thread already. This is embarrassing!
If the goal was to have a go at Brandon you all should of chosen a different way this is really sad!
IMO for clear results we need a environment that will mimic all of our tanks. I believe if this is made in a rush is set to fail. This test is only banking on ammonia as a food source to the bacteria. If the reading of po4 and no3 are zero is a big variable to not be taken into account don’t you think?

edit: for anyone that been in the hobby long enough can tell the colour of mature rock and new rock. The rock in this test doesn’t look mature, looks fresh from the shelf to me. The pic on the scales rock locks bone dry to!
Well - I've been in the hobby for a very long time - and I can tell you - I have rock in my sump (directly where the water comes in) - that gets no light and looks the same - and it's 15 years old. To me- the question would be 'what does the rest of the tank look like'. In any case - I was under the impression - from some here - that nitrifying bacteria will cover every surface of the tank.

Second - Nitrifying bacteria do not need 'nitrate'.
Third - I agree that there should be 'some' phosphate in the tank - and that it should be constant in both steps if possible.
Fourth - I would make sure the water temp and parameters are 'the same' in the old tank and the new tank (including the amount of light)
Fifth - I would consider putting the rock into the tank on day 0 - and adding ammonia on Day 1 - to give the bacteria a chance to 'adjust' to the 'new water'. Though - I'm not sure this is a huge deal - it wouldn't affect anything either (negatively) IMHO
 
Ok, it's a test. You can take from it what you wish.
So far from it, isn’t that the same rock as brs investigates considered the worst rock for surface bacteria, seen here at 11:30.

 

IF YOU HAD TO TAKE A REEFING EXAM, WOULD YOU PASS?

  • Yes!

    Votes: 30 44.8%
  • Not yet, but I have one that I want to buy in mind!

    Votes: 9 13.4%
  • No.

    Votes: 25 37.3%
  • Other (please explain).

    Votes: 3 4.5%
Back
Top