Should have done some literature searching to see if I could add some more data to the conversation before I posted my post but here is something I just found (
https://reefs.com/magazine/elementa...-skimmer-actually-remove-from-aquarium-water/). This article is very data heavy and I only skimmed through it, but the results may be surprising to some. Here is there conclusions from analyzing their tank's skimmate:
"The chemical/elemental composition of skimmate generated by an H&S 200-1260 skimmer on a 175-gallon reef tank over the course of several days or a week had some surprises. Only a minor amount of the skimmate (solid + liquid) could be attributed to organic carbon (TOC); about 29%, and most of that material was not water soluble, i.e., was not dissolved organic carbon. The majority of the recovered skimmate solid, apart from the commons ions of seawater, was CaCO3, MgCO3, and SiO2 – inorganic compounds! The origin of these
species is not known with certainity, but a good case can be made that the SiO2 stems from the shells of diatoms. The CaCO3 might be derived from other planktonic microbes bearing
calcium carbonate shells, or might come from calcium reactor effluent. To the extent that the solid skimmate consists of microflora, then some proportion of the insoluble organic material removed by skimming would then simply be the organic components (the “guts”) of these microflora. These microflora do concentrate P, N, and C nutrients from the water column, and so their removal via skimming does constitute a means of nutrient export."
I think one takeaway is that skimmate is actually comprised more of inorganic compounds than the organic materials we think of when we think of livestock waste. The other takeaway is that "results may vary", the composition of skimmate is almost certainly going to vary from tank to tank. So it is very possible that one reefer may dose their tanks with skimmate (intentionally or not) for 30 years in 100s of different tanks and also very possible that one reefer accidentally contaminates their water with skimmate and kills everything in their tank.
As some of this discussion has been about whether or not you would recommend doing this, I think it is a decision only the reefer looking to add more nutrients to their, can make based on a risk/benefit analysis. Are they willing to risk a bad outcome in their tank even though this might only happen 1% or less of the time? Or would they rather know exactly what they are adding back to their tank and look for a commercially available product to increase the nutrients in their tank? I think if you have unintentionally spilled skimmate into your tank, dosing your tank for nutrients with the skimmate is probably not much of a risk as you have already (unintentionally) done that before and presumably did not have any issues. If this has never happened, maybe the unknown amount of risk is too much for someone to attempt it.