Have you ever overflowed a skimmer collection cup?

Have you overflowed your skimmer collection cup releasing skimmate back into the system?

  • Yes

    Votes: 41 28.9%
  • No

    Votes: 13 9.2%
  • Multiple times

    Votes: 83 58.5%
  • I don't have a skimmer

    Votes: 5 3.5%

  • Total voters
    142
Was this during the most recent treatment that also got your blue hammer ?

So you had massive levels of fw toxin/fw exit in the skimmer cup? That is easily explainable.
Yup but who’s to say if it was the cup overflow, or what the skimmer was trying to remove
 
I have one other experience to share here before calling it quits for the night. I have a 29g qt tank that at one point I had a purple tang in. I kept a cup near the tank that I would dump some skimmate and put some old un eaten food (nori mostly) into. The contents of the cup were absolutely disgusting. I also used the same type of cup to add a little topoff water to the tank, well one night while about half asleep I accidentally dumped the disgusting cup into the tank instead of the top off water. The water was so dirty that I was not able to see inside the tank. I honestly expected this mistake to kill the fish, but it didn’t.
If we are talking about the amount of skimmate added to a certain tank size, surely enough that you can’t see through the water is an overly extreme case.
 
Yup but who’s to say if it was the cup overflow, or what the skimmer was trying to remove
I've seen your tank before the treatment homie. It was definitely the flatworm toxin/exit in the skimmer. That's Not your grandma's old skimmate in there.
 
I've seen your tank before the treatment homie. It was definitely the flatworm toxin/exit in the skimmer. That's Not your grandma's old skimmate in there.
My cup overflows easy. But who knows if my fish would have pulled through if I hadn’t let my skimmer overflow that night after introducing flatworm exit. Not only did it overflow but because I woke up to it at 2am I shut my skimmer off till the next mornings…..all bad
 
My fish have died before a skimmer overflow. The only time it’s happened to me after an overflow, the water in my cup was neon orange because I was dealing with a massive flatworm die off
valid reason for die off.
 
valid reason for die off.
@NowGlazeIT

link GIF


See you next weekend!!
 
I have one other experience to share here before calling it quits for the night. I have a 29g qt tank that at one point I had a purple tang in. I kept a cup near the tank that I would dump some skimmate and put some old un eaten food (nori mostly) into. The contents of the cup were absolutely disgusting. I also used the same type of cup to add a little topoff water to the tank, well one night while about half asleep I accidentally dumped the disgusting cup into the tank instead of the top off water. The water was so dirty that I was not able to see inside the tank. I honestly expected this mistake to kill the fish, but it didn’t.
If we are talking about the amount of skimmate added to a certain tank size, surely enough that you can’t see through the water is an overly extreme case.
At least you don't keep the nasty water in a big coffee mug...

Could you Even Imagine the violence of gagging...
 
Loose quote here.... "When all options have been explored fully, and no result has been found. Whatever remains, however unlikely, must be the truth." - Sir Arthur Conan Doyle

Is overflowing skimmate the reason for my brief and unexplained mortality rate? Perhaps not.

However, the results of cleaning the skimmer cup and consequent halt of mortality in my system are quite compelling evidence to reinforce the position I hold.

Again, I clarify this as this is MY system, Every system is unique, which I have stated before and your results may be different.
I don’t think you explored Every option. (No offense!) And for anyone to take that as evidence, we have to assume Every single other possibility Has been explored. This would require a Lot more information about Your system- specifically, when this event occurred.

Nobody is saying you are Wrong- but I believe the evidence points to there being another Cause… (What was causing your skimmer to overflow in the First place). Cleaning the skimmer and the subsequent halt in death doesn’t Mean that the skimmer/skimmate was the reason for the deaths. It is possible that something else happened, that caused a large die-off, and Also caused your skimmer to overflow…

Yup but who’s to say if it was the cup overflow, or what the skimmer was trying to remove

THIS. Regardless of tank size/other filtration involved, I think we can agree that the consensus is that the skim being dumped back in isn’t detrimental unless What is in the skim is actually harmful.
 
First 6 months of my tank,used to remove skimmer cup completely and pour down toilet then clean cup and replace but then over next week had to keep adjusting knows and that made skimmer cup overflow back into skimmer neck,probably some went back into sump then dt,never had it overflow outside of the skimmer cup.
But last 8 months I leave skimmer cup on and just open drain and drain into a bottle and lightly clean skimmer neck with a toothbrush and as water draining out of cup,use toothbrush to clean sides of cup with the wet skimmer that's draining.
Dont have to adjust knows this way and doesnt overflow and get a nice dark skimmate that I empty every wc which is every 1-1.5 weeks.
After 1-1.5 weeks skimmer cup like 50% full of dark skimmer.
I do feed quite heavy clams/oysters so choose to run wetter skimmate

20220603_133121.jpg 20220603_133124.jpg 20220603_133149.jpg
 
Last edited:
I have overflowed more times than I want to admit.
I do not purposely add it back to the tank but, I do take the cup off and clean that in the sink and take my toilet brush and clean the skimmer neck while the skimmer is running while in the sump.
So some of the crud is going back into the system and I have no adverse effects.
 
If it's doing what it's supposed to do, The only things in your skimmer, are what are already in your tank water, and to a very small extent, possibly particles from the air.. It's already there and you're already breathing it.
Loving this discussion! Maybe I missed someone bringing it up but if not here are some thoughts to ponder. As I was reading through the pages of this thread, this was exactly what I was thinking. If your skimmer is pulling out A and B from the water then the skimmate must have both A and B in it but just more concentrated. Then when @Jedi1199 said "Do we even know what is in it?" and then @Lost in the Sauce tagged the chemist @Randy Holmes-Farley , it made me think that the chemistry here is not as simple since the compounds of A and B in the aquarium water are not in equilibrium with that in the skimmate nor do they have the same environmental conditions.

I think it is very fair to question whether the contents of the skimmate are safe to return to the water when it is very possible what is in there is no longer the same as what it was when it was in the water. While the actual kinds of elements pulled out of the water will be in the skimmate, they way they existed in compounds in the aquarium water is surely not the same as it is in the skimmer. The skimmate is concentrated meaning chemical reaction rates can occur at much faster rates than they could in the aquarium. While I don't have the data, I can guarantee the pH of the skimmate is different. The skimmate also contains a higher concentration of bacteria and some bacteria only produce certain compounds once they reach a certain density using something called quorum sensing. It is very possible bacteria at the concentrations in the aquarium are not producing anything toxic until they are stuffed together in the skimmer. The microbiome of the skimmate may also be different than the aquarium itself (again back to differences in environments) and metabolic by-products of these bacteria could be toxic. Aquabiomics has shown that while there are some core bacteria in healthy aquariums, the amount of other species differs from tank to tank.

As we all know from the nitrogen cycle the difference of one oxygen can turn something toxic into something non-toxic (the reverse of course is also true). I would be interested to know what the chemists, microbiologists, and marine biologists think of this topic.

Disclaimer: I am know expert on these topics, my degrees are in biological sciences and I do mostly pulmonary and pharmacological research. I also do not even have a skimmer yet because currently I have more issues with keeping nutrients in the system than I do pulling them out.
 
That is a lot of reading. I have never accidentally or intentionally allowed the skim cup to over fill. HOB skimmers are scary at times. If something gets clogged, you can get an overflow taking place. It isn't skim mate, it's tank water. My hob reef octopus did this often. Took me awhile to figure out it was the sponge filter on the output pipe causing the issues.

Other method I do use intentionally, if medicating or bottoming out on N03 and P04. I remove the skim cup.

Now will skim mate harm live stock?
THIS. Regardless of tank size/other filtration involved, I think we can agree that the consensus is that the skim being dumped back in isn’t detrimental unless What is in the skim is actually harmful.
About as true as it gets.

6 pages of reading? I may catch up later. I have a sinus infection bothering me :(
 
Should have done some literature searching to see if I could add some more data to the conversation before I posted my post but here is something I just found (https://reefs.com/magazine/elementa...-skimmer-actually-remove-from-aquarium-water/). This article is very data heavy and I only skimmed through it, but the results may be surprising to some. Here is there conclusions from analyzing their tank's skimmate:

"The chemical/elemental composition of skimmate generated by an H&S 200-1260 skimmer on a 175-gallon reef tank over the course of several days or a week had some surprises. Only a minor amount of the skimmate (solid + liquid) could be attributed to organic carbon (TOC); about 29%, and most of that material was not water soluble, i.e., was not dissolved organic carbon. The majority of the recovered skimmate solid, apart from the commons ions of seawater, was CaCO3, MgCO3, and SiO2 – inorganic compounds! The origin of these species is not known with certainity, but a good case can be made that the SiO2 stems from the shells of diatoms. The CaCO3 might be derived from other planktonic microbes bearing calcium carbonate shells, or might come from calcium reactor effluent. To the extent that the solid skimmate consists of microflora, then some proportion of the insoluble organic material removed by skimming would then simply be the organic components (the “guts”) of these microflora. These microflora do concentrate P, N, and C nutrients from the water column, and so their removal via skimming does constitute a means of nutrient export."

I think one takeaway is that skimmate is actually comprised more of inorganic compounds than the organic materials we think of when we think of livestock waste. The other takeaway is that "results may vary", the composition of skimmate is almost certainly going to vary from tank to tank. So it is very possible that one reefer may dose their tanks with skimmate (intentionally or not) for 30 years in 100s of different tanks and also very possible that one reefer accidentally contaminates their water with skimmate and kills everything in their tank.

As some of this discussion has been about whether or not you would recommend doing this, I think it is a decision only the reefer looking to add more nutrients to their, can make based on a risk/benefit analysis. Are they willing to risk a bad outcome in their tank even though this might only happen 1% or less of the time? Or would they rather know exactly what they are adding back to their tank and look for a commercially available product to increase the nutrients in their tank? I think if you have unintentionally spilled skimmate into your tank, dosing your tank for nutrients with the skimmate is probably not much of a risk as you have already (unintentionally) done that before and presumably did not have any issues. If this has never happened, maybe the unknown amount of risk is too much for someone to attempt it.
 
This thread is what happens every time I go to bed.
Initially I thought this would be a "See dear, I told you it was normal to get fish poo all over the new floors" thread.
I have overflowed my skimmers too many times to count. I have also never suffered any losses due to it.
Now I have floats to prevent this but the float is on my remote collection reservoir. I have had the drain tube from the cup get plugged up and that causes the cup to overflow while also bypassing the switch, so it is not full proof.

As to @Jedi1199 and your losses, sorry to hear, that sucks. The only "issue" I had was when you said that cleaning your skimmer "solved" the problem. I take that to mean that you stopped losing fish. We do not know that those fish were going to die. It could be that the ones that died, did. The ones that did not die were not going to die. I wouldn't say that anything was definitively "solved". The clown trigger is the outlier IMO. They are very hearty and to lose one, to me, means that something else was going on.
 

IF YOU HAD TO TAKE A REEFING EXAM, WOULD YOU PASS?

  • Yes!

    Votes: 30 44.8%
  • Not yet, but I have one that I want to buy in mind!

    Votes: 9 13.4%
  • No.

    Votes: 25 37.3%
  • Other (please explain).

    Votes: 3 4.5%
Back
Top