Have you ever overflowed a skimmer collection cup?

Have you overflowed your skimmer collection cup releasing skimmate back into the system?

  • Yes

    Votes: 41 28.9%
  • No

    Votes: 13 9.2%
  • Multiple times

    Votes: 83 58.5%
  • I don't have a skimmer

    Votes: 5 3.5%

  • Total voters
    142
That also sounds disgusting!!! I'm imagining a fire hydrant of fish poo..
No it wasn’t the skimmate, just the tank water that made the fountain. So not disgusting just splashed water everywhere making a mess and destroying some electronics. That was when I decided to buy a skimmer that was built within the last decade.
 
Forgot to connect my remote skimmer cup storage hose, it went a few days before it tripped the leak detector. It was a bit rank in the stand, had to put a fan on it. I was glad I coated the inside of the stand with flexseal.
Seems like a good reason to put a float switch on it to shut off the skimmer when the container is full.
 
No it wasn’t the skimmate, just the tank water that made the fountain. So not disgusting just splashed water everywhere making a mess and destroying some electronics. That was when I decided to buy a skimmer that was built within the last decade.
Less disgusting now for sure
 
Prove it.
What was that?
PXL_20220603_045951556.jpg


I'm unsure if you are aware but writing letters on yourself upside down with sharpie is not as easy as it looks.
 
Seems like a good reason to put a float switch on it to shut off the skimmer when the container is full.
I have a float switch. I screwed up when I drained the remote vessel I use. I forgot to connect the silicone hose leading from the skimmers cup to the remote storage. Normally no issue, but I tend to do a lot of tank work at midnight when dumba$$ery is high, lol.

EDIT: I forgot to connect that bad boy, which made my living room smell of a sewer. Upside the stand is sealed so it didnt get to the wood floors!

20220602_220527_HDR~2.jpg
 
Last edited:
Just out of curiosity.... Is there even a test kit, aside from a laboratory, that can give accurate results as to what exactly is in skimmate? I mean, we all know that skimmers remove pollutants... what exactly is in that nasty cup of goo?

Does anyone actually know exactly what it is?
 
So you dump on a clear load, back into the tank, but clear out heavy skim?
If it's a weeks worth of skimmate (even if it's yellowish/clearish) I'll get rid of it. If it's fresh stuff that's happened in the space of a few minutes or hours since adjusting the skimmer flow, back in it goes.

Sorry for confusion.
I feel your pain! I'm running the bubble mag curve 7 elite, And it is the most finickiest skimmer. A turn so slight on the water adjustment valve can turn the concentrate from gooey, to overflowing.

I've also experienced skimmer cups rebreaking in after being washed. Not the neck, Just the cup, And this caused an overflow situation for 10 days straight until enough deposits were left to make it work again..

When it's dialed in that thing is dialed in ! Just don't change anything .Frustrating to say the least.

Yeah mines an Octo 110SS I think it's called.
Absolute pain. I can get it right at times, but then if you do a water change and turn it on too quickly before the pump recirculates the water appropriately then out she goes again.
Still trying to fine tune it after putting the system together again in the past couple months. Every now and then I can see build up in the neck that isn't making it to the cup, so I adjusted by what feels like 1-2 mm, 20 minutes later I can hear it bubbling out of the breather holes.
 
bottom line ?
if you were bottoming out on phos % no3 on a 100 gal system
A , go to bacteria in a bottle
B, dump a shot glass of skimmate in.
i choose B
 
Just out of curiosity.... Is there even a test kit, aside from a laboratory, that can give accurate results as to what exactly is in skimmate? I mean, we all know that skimmers remove pollutants... what exactly is in that nasty cup of goo?

Does anyone actually know exactly what it is?
I wonder how excited Triton Labs would be about doing an ICP test on a specimen cup of skimmate...

Gags a little...

But in all seriousness, It should be all of these solids that are everywhere else in our water, above a certain size. I have only read about 6 in deep into hydraulic surface fracturing so by no means am the expert on it.
 
If it's a weeks worth of skimmate (even if it's yellowish/clearish) I'll get rid of it. If it's fresh stuff that's happened in the space of a few minutes or hours since adjusting the skimmer flow, back in it goes.

Sorry for confusion.


Yeah mines an Octo 110SS I think it's called.
Absolute pain. I can get it right at times, but then if you do a water change and turn it on too quickly before the pump recirculates the water appropriately then out she goes again.
Still trying to fine tune it after putting the system together again in the past couple months. Every now and then I can see build up in the neck that isn't making it to the cup, so I adjusted by what feels like 1-2 mm, 20 minutes later I can hear it bubbling out of the breather holes.
What level is it sitting at? If you fed recently/there are excess nutrients in tank from Not skimming, it will overflow if you don’t dial it back. Mine takes a precise tune in when cleaned. When it’s a little Dirty, I can adjust it easily. I have my skimmer about 4 inches above the bottom of my sump, and the only time it overflows is after a cleaning (when it hasn’t been tuned in) or if the tank drains into the sump ((obviously)). I’ve never had it overflow due to any other reasons.
 
To further that thought.. How about a poll.. Do you dump unknown stuff into your tank? I mean, if nobody knows exactly what is in skimmate, how could anyone, in good conscious advise adding it back to the system. In what amounts? To combat what? And, if there is a desired effect, how much of what unknown elements are being reintroduced to the system?

The catalyst for this thread was a post regarding a tank that is bottoming out on Nitrates.

I agree with @Lost in the Sauce that a more general input is valuable in this discussion.

Now, if we can concentrate on our own personal experience, which I believe was the goal of this thread, can we please get on topic and discuss that which we want to know? IN YOUR EXPERIENCE, is skimmate a plus or minus to your tank, Why? Please discuss ONLY your own experiences. Also, please let's eliminate as many variables as possible. Please post exactly what your own tank filtration system involves.

I know we are 5 pages in, but nothing has been resolved here save for 90+ posts of opinions.

I for one, would appreciate scientific data to back up the opinions.
 
To further that thought.. How about a poll.. Do you dump unknown stuff into your tank? I mean, if nobody knows exactly what is in skimmate, how could anyone, in good conscious advise adding it back to the system. In what amounts? To combat what? And, if there is a desired effect, how much of what unknown elements are being reintroduced to the system?

The catalyst for this thread was a post regarding a tank that is bottoming out on Nitrates.

I agree with @Lost in the Sauce that a more general input is valuable in this discussion.

Now, if we can concentrate on our own personal experience, which I believe was the goal of this thread, can we please get on topic and discuss that which we want to know? IN YOUR EXPERIENCE, is skimmate a plus or minus to your tank, Why? Please discuss ONLY your own experiences. Also, please let's eliminate as many variables as possible. Please post exactly what your own tank filtration system involves.

I know we are 5 pages in, but nothing has been resolved here save for 90+ posts of opinions.

I for one, would appreciate scientific data to back up the opinions.
I’m not trying to argue but I’ve seen many posts where people have said that when skimmate has gone back into their tanks (myself included) it hasn’t caused any problems, I fail to see how that is an opinion.
 
I’m not trying to argue but I’ve seen many posts where people have said that when skimmate has gone back into their tanks (myself included) it hasn’t caused any problems, I fail to see how that is an opinion.

Do you assume that every post you read is fact? What if you read a post where someone says something different? As the case here.. is the differing opinion a liar? Did he/she do something wrong? What variables were taken into account on each topic?
 
Do you assume that every post you read is fact?
When the post is someone sharing personal experience then yes I have to assume what they are saying is factual. Why would someone lie about not having an issue with skimmate going back into their tank?
I also assume you’re telling the truth when you said skimmate went into your tank and you started having problems.
 

IF YOU HAD TO TAKE A REEFING EXAM, WOULD YOU PASS?

  • Yes!

    Votes: 30 44.8%
  • Not yet, but I have one that I want to buy in mind!

    Votes: 9 13.4%
  • No.

    Votes: 25 37.3%
  • Other (please explain).

    Votes: 3 4.5%
Back
Top