Most likely cause of symptomless deaths

  • Thread starter Thread starter PDR
  • Start date Start date
  • Tagged users None
Something is obviously eating away at his scales. I’m unsure if it’s a worm, parasite or something bacterial though.

The only other med I have on hand is prazipro. Can I mix prazi and furan 2?
 
Another update. The gramma is still alive but seems to be breathing heavier, slow but heavy. Still no other visible symptoms but he is easily blown around the tank if he gets out of the pvc. I'm continuing the Furan treatment but honestly, I don't have high hopes that he'll make it.
 
Another update. The gramma is still alive but seems to be breathing heavier, slow but heavy. Still no other visible symptoms but he is easily blown around the tank if he gets out of the pvc. I'm continuing the Furan treatment but honestly, I don't have high hopes that he'll make it.
Glad he'd still alive and hopefully may make a recovery.
 
The gramma died yesterday. :( I found him on the floor next to the QT. I didn't have a screen top made for it since it was an emergency setup, but I was using eggcrate to try and make it harder for him to jump, needless to say, it didn't help. I'm really surprised he had the energy to jump as he was just floating around the qt barely breathing the night before.

I examined him thoroughly and I did not see any signs of infection or parasites. He did have some nipped fins and some scales missing that I had mentioned earlier, but I really believe that was from the other tank inhabitants picking on him in his weakened state. Over the several days in QT, the fins and scales did not get any worse.

All other fish that were in the DT tank with him are still acting perfectly normal and show no signs of parasite or infection.

I would really appreciate some educated guesses on what could have killed him and not affect any other tank mates.
 
Other than the wrasse probably dying of old age, it sounds like most of your dead fish are sort of bottom dwellers.
The blennies and gramma come up in the water column but spend a lot of time down near the sand.

I hate pistol shrimp the way some people hate 6 lines so I may be biased.

What type of pistol is it?

If its not a tiny candy cane/randalls that is my first guess.

If they came close and it popped its claw the concussion might have been enough to damage them without killing them.

That is just my best guess.

Sorry about the gramma.
 
So sorry for your losses. I also believe the wrasse was an advanced age. I have lost mine through this and it is very sad. I will only by juveniles now as we do not get that much time with them.

Do you have access to a microscope? You can scrape the fins, tail, scales and see if you spot any parasites there.

No obvious symptoms really is hard to handle the losses. If you see any others begin to waste away, I would do what you did for others and try getting them out and run through a parasite treatment regiment.

I hope all the rest do fine for you.
 
The symptoms displayed by the grey-head sound a lot like advanced age to me . . .

Most of the wrasses we keep seem to live about five years - if this fellow was full-sized when you got him, it may well have just been ... his time.

~Bruce
I was gonna say.... you never know how old an adult fish is when you get it. Also, there’s no telling how it was collected. Sorry you’ve had all this happen. We have all experienced stuff like this.
 
Other than the wrasse probably dying of old age, it sounds like most of your dead fish are sort of bottom dwellers.
The blennies and gramma come up in the water column but spend a lot of time down near the sand.

I hate pistol shrimp the way some people hate 6 lines so I may be biased.

What type of pistol is it?

If its not a tiny candy cane/randalls that is my first guess.

If they came close and it popped its claw the concussion might have been enough to damage them without killing them.

That is just my best guess.

Sorry about the gramma.

It is a small candy cane pistol maybe 1" long.

So sorry for your losses. I also believe the wrasse was an advanced age. I have lost mine through this and it is very sad. I will only by juveniles now as we do not get that much time with them.

Do you have access to a microscope? You can scrape the fins, tail, scales and see if you spot any parasites there.

No obvious symptoms really is hard to handle the losses. If you see any others begin to waste away, I would do what you did for others and try getting them out and run through a parasite treatment regiment.

I hope all the rest do fine for you.

I don't have a microscope. To be clear, the royal gramma did not experience any of the wasting that others had. I can't remember if I mentioned this but I do have several mini maxis, so some of the mystery disappearances could potentially be from them.

I was gonna say.... you never know how old an adult fish is when you get it. Also, there’s no telling how it was collected. Sorry you’ve had all this happen. We have all experienced stuff like this.

Yeah, I agree the wrasse was most likely age-related.

The fish that wasted away were few and far between, and they did not exhibit any of the common symptoms associated with internal parasites.

At this point, I am really the most curious as to what could have caused the grammas death. Mainly because I want to be able to get ahead of it if it starts happening to any of the other fish.
 
I have seen so many captive fish and on necropsy the livers look terrible. I do not know if this was cause of death in all cases, but certainly was a contributor. Seems that some fish just waste away in captivity. Could be capture method (stress), could be diet, could be bacterial or viral, never have seen answers to the liver issues. I have seen some studies with diet being an issue. You also have cyanide capture as an issue too.

Hard to tell sometimes as we do not always know the history of the fish. We have to do our best and sounds like you are. I would maybe try a antibiotic protocol with them if they show symptoms too. Of course, could effect the liver. I am running kanaplex and metronisazole currently in one of my qts. I haven't a clue what is going on with them. These are fish I have had for years and during my move to a new tank, the stress brought something out. Lost a lot. Hoping these guys make it.

Good luck to you.
 
So this is slightly off topic, but I feel like I have to vent.

I have been reading a lot on quarantining fish, disease treatment, etc. To do it right, you essentially need another room in the house for at least two tanks (and those are just for the fish, not coral or invert). Not only does that take up a lot of room (room I personally just don't have), but also takes a considerable amount of time, effort and money. And even then, it's not like it has a 100% success rate.

I just watched an interview of Paul Poeschl from MACNA and he talked about how it is our responsibility to properly qt fish from an ethical standpoint. It got me thinking, why in the heck do we continue to put up with the ridiculous amount of parasites, disease, and infection that is so rampant in the industry these days?

It is basically guaranteed (and expected) that any fish purchased will have some sort of parasite, infection, etc. So not only are we spending 100's if not 1000's of dollars for these diseased fish but now we have to spend even more time and money quarantining and medicating them just to hope that some of them make it through.

I'm sorry, but this is just completely ridiculous. In what other industry would this be put up with?

Ok rant over lol.
 
Last edited:
So this is slightly off topic, but I feel like I have to vent.

I have been reading a lot on quarantining fish, disease treatment, etc. To do it right, you essentially need another room in the house for at least two tanks (and those are just for the fish, not coral or invert). Not only does that take up a lot of room (room I personally just don't have), but also takes a considerable amount of time, effort and money. And even then, it's not like it has a 100% success rate.

I just watched an interview of Paul Poeschl from MACNA and he talked about how it is our responsibility to properly qt fish from an ethical standpoint. It got me thinking, why in the heck do we continue to put up with the ridiculous amount of parasites, disease, and infection that is so rampant in the industry these days?

It is basically guaranteed (and expected) that any fish purchased will have some sort of parasite, infection, etc. So not only are we spending 100's if not 1000's of dollars for these diseased fish but now we have to spend even more time and money quarantining and medicating them just to hope that some of them make it through.

I'm sorry, but this is just completely ridiculous. In what other industry would this be put up with?

Ok rant over lol.

I agree. There is no regulation whatsoever. So it is what we are left with in many facets of this hobby, well beyond receiving sick fish to start with.

My fear is, if regulations were put into place, what would happen? I don't think we would end up with disease free fish at the end of the day. I think it would basically cripple the industry to the point of non-existence.

We have to figure it out ourselves.

QTing properly requires a shelf full of meds, alot of observational time while fish are in QTs. For me though (I am NUTS) it's my favorite part of the hobby. Or the end outcome is the most rewarding I guess...
 
So this is slightly off topic, but I feel like I have to vent.

I have been reading a lot on quarantining fish, disease treatment, etc. To do it right, you essentially need another room in the house for at least two tanks (and those are just for the fish, not coral or invert). Not only does that take up a lot of room (room I personally just don't have), but also takes a considerable amount of time, effort and money. And even then, it's not like it has a 100% success rate.

I just watched an interview of Paul Poeschl from MACNA and he talked about how it is our responsibility to properly qt fish from an ethical standpoint. It got me thinking, why in the heck do we continue to put up with the ridiculous amount of parasites, disease, and infection that is so rampant in the industry these days?

It is basically guaranteed (and expected) that any fish purchased will have some sort of parasite, infection, etc. So not only are we spending 100's if not 1000's of dollars for these diseased fish but now we have to spend even more time and money quarantining and medicating them just to hope that some of them make it through.

I'm sorry, but this is just completely ridiculous. In what other industry would this be put up with?

Ok rant over lol.
The root of this is in the fact that people will always pay ridiculous prices, even if the product isn't what it once was....ESPECIALLY in this hobby. Being a Computer Scientist has afforded me the understanding that if I don't like something, I can just code it better. Look at Rajib who was like 'uhm no.' to Apex and volunteered his time to ensure we had another cost effective option.

People simply do not care enough to stop buying fish and force change in industry. It's easier to set up a QT. I have one, and only one QT because my fiance would kill me if I decided to set up tanks all over the house.

On top of this ridiculous double standard of price vs reward, there's the question of ethics...which could, and would be debated by many on each end of the spectrum on what is ethical or not ethical.
 
The real question is if someone sold a yellow tang for $40 without QT and someone else sold the same fish for $240 (or make up another large number) I don't think enough people would buy the latter.

Many will say $240 is ridiculous but I'm sure industrial levels of QT will have losses, holding costs, more losses due to QT time and processes and STILL they couldn't garuntee parasite free. I'm not sure anyone could ever advertise that. The best someone could do is like Algae Barn. "Clean Chaeto" with an advised QT caveat. No bag on them, it's just logical. Unless you captive bred like ORA and then sell direct to public, you really couldn't make such a claim.

And now I'll remind everyone, no one forces people into this hobby. Not to be rude but if you don't feel the efforts necessary are in your means, it's not the hobby for you maybe. If the real estate of tanks is the issue, pay someone else to QT your fish.

Edit: flame suit on. I'm ready. ;)

Also idk a QT service but the free market is a heck of a system. Make the demand.

Edit 2: Most people don't QT cuz of lack of self discipline, not money. People want their purchase NOW, in their DT NOW. Be honest with yourself. It's not the last fish this comes in, you need the self discipline with the FIRST fish. And after that, and this is better than I do, but also with EVERY wet thing after that.
 
Last edited:
The real question is if someone sold a yellow tang for $40 without QT and someone else sold the same fish for $240 (or make up another large number) I don't think enough people would buy the latter.

I read this a lot, so I created a poll on it to see what people are actually willing to pay. https://www.reef2reef.com/threads/poll-how-much-more-would-you-pay-for-quarantined-fish.467908/

And now I'll remind everyone, no one forces people into this hobby. Not to be rude but if you don't feel the efforts necessary are in your means, it's not the hobby for you maybe. If the real estate of tanks is the issue, pay someone else to QT your fish.

While true, your comment alienates 90%+ of hobbyists. To suggest that someone who does not have the funds, time or space should not be able to take part in this wonderful hobby comes across as a little arrogant and elitist and more along the lines of what I would expect from RC.

Personally speaking, I would be more than happy to pay someone to qt my fish. Unfortunately, I do not have an LFS in my area that offers that service and I do not know of any other hobbyists in the area that would be able or willing to do it. As soon as humblefish gets up and running I plan to purchase all my fish from him. In the meantime, I do the best I can by purchasing captive bred or from DD. While not perfect, it is the best practice I have found considering my situation.

FWIW based on posts I read on here, it seems that for everyone who qt's properly, there are 5-10 who do it wrong and either end up killing the fish or still introducing parasites. It's also worth noting that there are prominent hobbyists who never qt and have had great success (PaulB).
I'm not necessarily advocating that practice, but it does show there is more than one way to be successful in the hobby.
 

IF YOU HAD TO TAKE A REEFING EXAM, WOULD YOU PASS?

  • Yes!

    Votes: 30 44.8%
  • Not yet, but I have one that I want to buy in mind!

    Votes: 9 13.4%
  • No.

    Votes: 25 37.3%
  • Other (please explain).

    Votes: 3 4.5%
Back
Top