Pink fish for ten gallon and 20 gallon

Earl Karl

Well-Known Member
View Badges
Joined
Jul 29, 2017
Messages
911
Reaction score
581
Location
Under your bed.
What state or country do you live in
Florida
Rating - 0%
0   0   0
So I want a pink fish each for my little ten gallon and my 20g. Obviously I can't really go wrasses, although I wish. Also I am not gonna drop hundreds on a candy basslet. Is there a pink fish (not purple, pink), that can live in a 10 gallon and my 20 gallon?
 
While not exactly pink, the helfrichi firefish are beautiful.
 
Purple firefish arent pink but they're stunning
 
Helfrichi firefish is pretty pink, but costs a bit more. Royal Gramma is kind of deep purple/yellow if that's a look you like?
 
Coral croucher is another nano sized fish. Will kinda look pink with the red dots on the white background.
 
I would like to avoid "flesh" color fish. Pink streaked wrasse is an example.

Again NO PURPLE FISH.

I LOVE the McCosker, but it is too active for my 20.

Helfrichi looks nice, except I don't like firefish in general since they are skittish and short lived compared to other fish.

I really like the Trimma Goby, but I want something free swimming and easy to get. My lfs will probably never get these.

So basically I am just looking for nice pink (not fleshy), free swimming, relatively inexpensive (>50$), easy to get, and decently long lived (5 years +) fish.

I would have gone with a sixline, but I have too many in different tanks and I have a Ruby Red scooter in the 20g (He eats frozen 3 times a day and 10 gallon refugium). But the wrasse might decimate pod population.
 
upload_2018-10-7_0-0-31.jpeg

Pink skunk clown
 
Well, looks like I'm going with a six line wrasse since there seems to be no options. I already own 25 of these in my other bunch of tanks for pest control though, but looks like I'm just gonna get another one. Looks like I'm going to have to feed my Ruby Red Scooter four times a day instead of three.

For the ten gallon, I'm just gonna put my yellow assessor there.
 
If willing to do a temperate tank, and wait for availability there is the multibarred goby.
5099d9a00f86b0aa84bef30b644194a9.jpg


Not a tropical fish, if want a reef this not the fish unless doing a tank of strawberry anemones.
 
If willing to do a temperate tank, and wait for availability there is the multibarred goby.
5099d9a00f86b0aa84bef30b644194a9.jpg


Not a tropical fish, if want a reef this not the fish unless doing a tank of strawberry anemones.
I keep my tanks 77-78, not a good idea. I like to keep all of my tanks similar to each other. Plus I want free swimming fish.
 
Sixlines and dragonets are not a good combination. First, even though the dragonet may be eating foods provided by you, the bulk of it's dietary needs is from eating pods. Secondly, sixlines can be particularly aggressive toward other pod eaters, often going after the eyes of dragonets.
 
Going after eyes of dragonets? I have many frags systems (Most of them being 30 gallon shallows) with the combo and I have never seen that type of aggression. The only fish I would avoid putting with a six line is a dottyback, now that is pecking eyes out action.

I just love how there just been few cases where this happens (I only found one case that happened and it was years ago), and people just make it a staple. When in reality there are probably thousands of us who have the combo and never experienced this issue. It's only the negative that gets pointed out and the six line gets a HORRIFIC reputation.
Yes, some may vary and become little hellions, I have 2 out of 25 that just chases damsels now and then. It probably is a feeding issue if anything. I feed my fish at least 3 times a day, you can't really expect these fish to have a slower metabolism than creatures like humans who are thousands times bigger and eat three meals a day. Most of us probably feed these guys 1-2 times a day. Fish definitely have a higher metabolism, let alone a constant pod eater like a six line. Again, it is more of a feeding issue, rather than just pure hellish behavior. And those who feed that much or more and still get that aggressive behavior? Who knows, feed more. Maybe the six line has a very high metabolism, it just tolerates it better than a dragonet. I just think the six line wrasse is very well misunderstood. In fact, feeding in general is well misunderstood as fish in the ocean get constant VERY SMALL feedings throughout the day (at least the smaller fishes). Not just one big meal.

If there isn't any other fish, I'm going with a six line. I don't really like this option, since I have so many of them. If only there was a flasher that was only an inch long.
 
Last edited:
Going after eyes of dragonets? I have many frags systems (Most of them being 30 gallon shallows) with the combo and I have never seen that type of aggression. The only fish I would avoid putting with a six line is a dottyback, now that is pecking eyes out action.

I just love how there just been few cases where this happens (I only found one case that happened and it was years ago), and people just make it a staple. When in reality there are probably thousands of us who have the combo and never experienced this issue. It's only the negative that gets pointed out and the six line gets a HORRIFIC reputation.
Yes, some may vary and become little hellions, I have 2 out of 25 that just chases damsels now and then. It probably is a feeding issue if anything. I feed my fish at least 3 times a day, you can't really expect these fish to have a slower metabolism than creatures like humans who are thousands times bigger and eat three meals a day. Most of us probably feed these guys 1-2 times a day. Fish definitely have a higher metabolism, let alone a constant pod eater like a six line. Again, it is more of a feeding issue, rather than just pure hellish behavior. And those who feed that much or more and still get that aggressive behavior? Who knows, feed more. Maybe the six line has a very high metabolism, it just tolerates it better than a dragonet. I just think the six line wrasse is very well misunderstood. In fact, feeding in general is well misunderstood as fish in the ocean get constant VERY SMALL feedings throughout the day (at least the smaller fishes). Not just one big meal.

If there isn't any other fish, I'm going with a six line. I don't really like this option, since I have so many of them. If only there was a flasher that was only an inch long.
I've had a few in the last couple of years do that. They were fine temporarily then one day snapped.

Since these fish were fed more than 3x's a day, they were fed a minimum of 5x's a day, I don't think it was a feeding issue.

I am trying to help you from my own experience, and that has been confirmed by others.

Will a sixline definitely go after the eyes? Not definitely, but the fact that it is a reasonable possibility should factor in your decision.
 
I've had a few in the last couple of years do that. They were fine temporarily then one day snapped.

Since these fish were fed more than 3x's a day, they were fed a minimum of 5x's a day, I don't think it was a feeding issue.

I am trying to help you from my own experience, and that has been confirmed by others.

Will a sixline definitely go after the eyes? Not definitely, but the fact that it is a reasonable possibility should factor in your decision.
Maybe they need more than that. Who knows, they might have the metabolism of a mandarin, they just tolerate it better. I should have phrased it better, but what matters is the amount of food per day. I usually feed them until their bellies swells (their belly can really swell) and I make sure they eat nutrient dense foods. May seem like overfeeding, but is it really that much different than what we aim towards for our dragonets? Again, there are hellions out there. However it is true that if you keep their bellies full, they usually leave things alone, it just has to be constant. I kept a tessalata with some purple queen anthias and and a bunch of wrasses, I just fed him constantly.

Unless you have a better suggestion, I probably will go with a sixline, they are good pest control if anything. But I'm just looking for aesthetics for this tank.
 

IF YOU HAD TO TAKE A REEFING EXAM, WOULD YOU PASS?

  • Yes!

    Votes: 30 44.8%
  • Not yet, but I have one that I want to buy in mind!

    Votes: 9 13.4%
  • No.

    Votes: 25 37.3%
  • Other (please explain).

    Votes: 3 4.5%
Back
Top