Rock Flower Anemone - Dip in Bayer - Is it Safe?

Oh and BTW. .. it's good to have some in your tanks medicine cabinet just in case a coral starts acting strange or dying. It sometimes will fix whatever was causing the issue and bring it back to health
 
I really don't think a dip in anyway is needed honestly. Dipping a nem would be just like dipping a fish. There's no real need.
 
Oh and BTW. .. it's good to have some in your tanks medicine cabinet just in case a coral starts acting strange or dying. It sometimes will fix whatever was causing the issue and bring it back to health

I have some whatever brand iodide that I dip my zoas in if the don't open up. seems to work have only lost one frag of zoas.
 
I have used flatworm exit as a dip on zoa for zoa eating nudibranch. I would use it during acclimation in one gallon. I used 4 drops (way more than recommended) and it had no ill effect on the corals.

Maybe I will do that then.

Thanks.
 
I wouldn't dip no nem in anything I've had my share of nems had mine for 2 years was the longest I've been able to keep them alive.
 
Seems to me common sense that your not going to bath an anemone in insecticide, and why would you?
Agree.

The fundamental question which hasn't been addressed here; what exactly are you (OP) hoping to achieve by dipping a nem?
 
I think he's just worried about getting bad things in his tank. Aefw or red bugs.

I'm not real familiar with Nem's but I really don't think they carry any form of hitchhikers that would affect corals.

Not like frags or maybe rock would.
 
The title of the thread or opening post needs to be more inclusive then. Like, Experience with dipping Anemones in Bayer, otherwise you're going to get members like me trying to offer assistance only to be informed that unless you have actual first hand experience you're wasting your time posting here.

I am thankful for every person that takes the time to respond to any thread I have ever created.
 
Last edited:
Does anyone here have some websites I could check out for tips on having a Frogspawn coral. I use to have one but got ahead of myself ended up killing it within 3weeks of having it. But I would like to own a Frogspawn coral they are very neat to have
 
Well you Dip Corals in Insecticide so why not an Anemone?

Yes, maybe it is going to kill the Nem but maybe it will not.

That is why I asked the question.

I really do not know but really need to know.

People are entitled to their opinions and I do appreciate them but I really need to hear from somebody that actually tried it.

If somebody actually tried it and had no problems then I will do it.

And if they did have issues I will not do it.

I do not want to kill it so I am basing it off other peoples past experiences so I do not make any mistakes (saying others made the mistake that is because maybe it works. I don't know).


I know that putting my hand in fire will burn me. I don't need to know from experience of others to know this. Invertebrates in general are extremely sensitive creatures. That is not opinion and it is not guessing. Why do you think proper acclimation is far longer than the other animals we keep? Part of taking up the responsibility of keeping these creatures is adhering to sound advice that we may not actually want to hear.
But you seem hell bent on doing something stupid and incredibly cruel. So go ahead and do it. Be the first person and when you come on here to complain and ask for help that your nem is dying because you've dipped it anyways, then we'll tell you we told you so.
 
Lol. Are you trying to kill it or keep it? Dip it if u want to kill it or at least shock it bad enough to bleach it. They don't carry pests
 
Last edited:
Agree.

The fundamental question which hasn't been addressed here; what exactly are you (OP) hoping to achieve by dipping a nem?

I do not want to get Flatworms into my Tank that is why I want to Dip.
 
Lol. Are you trying to kill it or keep it? Dip it if u want to kill it or at least shock it bad enough to bleach it. They don't carry pests

How do you know they do not carry Pests?

I have seen Tanks with Tens of Thousands of Flatworms and they covered everything.

It is not like they are Acro Eating Flatworms or Zoa eating Nudi's that only eat those Corals.

Flatworms get everywhere (Glass, Equipment, Rock, Sand, Coral, etc. - So why would they not go onto Anemones as Well)?
 
I know that putting my hand in fire will burn me. I don't need to know from experience of others to know this. Invertebrates in general are extremely sensitive creatures. That is not opinion and it is not guessing. Why do you think proper acclimation is far longer than the other animals we keep? Part of taking up the responsibility of keeping these creatures is adhering to sound advice that we may not actually want to hear.
But you seem hell bent on doing something stupid and incredibly cruel. So go ahead and do it. Be the first person and when you come on here to complain and ask for help that your nem is dying because you've dipped it anyways, then we'll tell you we told you so.

I am taking responsibility that is why I asked the question here.

I find it hard to believe that nobody has ever tried Dipping them?

I just want to know concrete results that is all.

You know touching fire is bad because others who actually did it or know others that did it told you so - It is not because you assume it is bad for you
 
Lots and lots of assumptions in this thread and no one with experience (of Bayer dipping nems).

Everyone would think the same about Tridacna clams yet they seem to survive Bayer dips no problem (look it up if you don't believe).

It appears to depend largely on the animals complexity of central nervous system.

Given the risks I personally wouldn't do it, but I would love to hear some experiences from some that have. I have a feeling that it not hurt the nem at all, but its just a hunch.
 
I am taking responsibility that is why I asked the question here.
But you are not taking responsibility in following the advice given.
I find it hard to believe that nobody has ever tried Dipping them?
Because we know enough of what bayer does, and how sensitive nems are. We don't have to base our experience off of what someone else does.
I just want to know concrete results that is all.

You know touching fire is bad because others who actually did it or know others that did it told you so - It is not because you assume it is bad for you
I know that fire is hot. I know that I have a nervous system that feels intense pain from hot fire. And EVEN if I learned from someone tells me not to do it because I will get hurt, I'm not dumb enough to go eagerly try it. I won't even consider it.

If you are concerned about the rock that it is on, slowly blast the nem with water at it's base and it will release it's foot. Chuck the rock if that's your issue. But DO NOT DIP THE NEM. Put your nem in quarantine and go from there.
 
How insecticides work

This is explains how insecticides such as Bayer affects the nervous system. Anemones have a nervous system, and as such, WILL be affected by what Bayer does.

Sea anemone - Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia

This explains the anatomy of an anemone. It has a nervous system in which it receives impulses from stimuli, which would get hindered by Bayer, with or without a brain. Since it is completely ingesting the surrounding water with Bayer to inflate and deflate, it will likely destroy the anemone based on what the insecticide does.

I do not need to know from experience of others or myself to know that dipping the anemone is a bad idea and shouldn't be done. This isn't opinion. This is fact. 2+2=4. Bayer isn't 100% effective, either. I appreciate that you have seeked advice on the matter, but it doesn't have to be given by people who have experienced first hand.
If you want to be the first to try it, then so be it. Who am I to stop you? But it's not needed. If you do, document everything. Photos, time dipped, the dosage, the process you took to transfer it to your tank, and your tank params. Document several weeks after the dip as well.

Let me ask you this, would you dip a fish in Bayer? Why not? No one else has done it, and according to your logic, if flatworms exist elsewhere on and in the tank, why would it not live on the fish?
 
How insecticides work

This is explains how insecticides such as Bayer affects the nervous system. Anemones have a nervous system, and as such, WILL be affected by what Bayer does.

Sea anemone - Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia

This explains the anatomy of an anemone. It has a nervous system in which it receives impulses from stimuli, which would get hindered by Bayer, with or without a brain. Since it is completely ingesting the surrounding water with Bayer to inflate and deflate, it will likely destroy the anemone based on what the insecticide does.

I do not need to know from experience of others or myself to know that dipping the anemone is a bad idea and shouldn't be done. This isn't opinion. This is fact. 2+2=4. Bayer isn't 100% effective, either. I appreciate that you have seeked advice on the matter, but it doesn't have to be given by people who have experienced first hand.
If you want to be the first to try it, then so be it. Who am I to stop you? But it's not needed. If you do, document everything. Photos, time dipped, the dosage, the process you took to transfer it to your tank, and your tank params. Document several weeks after the dip as well.

Let me ask you this, would you dip a fish in Bayer? Why not? No one else has done it, and according to your logic, if flatworms exist elsewhere on and in the tank, why would it not live on the fish?

From the Sea Anemone page:
"A primitive nervous system, without centralization, coordinates the processes involved in maintaining homeostasis, as well as biochemical and physical responses to various stimuli. No specialized sense organs are present."

From the Bivalve page (clams):
"The animals have no brain; the nervous system consists of a nerve network and a series of paired ganglia. "

Both have
nervous systems. Yet Bayer does not harm clams at all. I think you shouldn't be so certain about your "2+2=4".
 
If you are concerned about the rock that it is on, slowly blast the nem with water at it's base and it will release it's foot. Chuck the rock if that's your issue. But DO NOT DIP THE NEM. Put your nem in quarantine and go from there.

It will not be on a rock so I do not have to worry about that.
 
Lots and lots of assumptions in this thread and no one with experience (of Bayer dipping nems).

Everyone would think the same about Tridacna clams yet they seem to survive Bayer dips no problem (look it up if you don't believe).

It appears to depend largely on the animals complexity of central nervous system.

Given the risks I personally wouldn't do it, but I would love to hear some experiences from some that have. I have a feeling that it not hurt the nem at all, but its just a hunch.

Awesome somebody gets where I am coming from!

I am sure the guy who got the idea to use Bayer asked around and everyone called him an idiot for even mentioning it.

I would as it sounds very very scary.

I was very scarred to use it but I did and have dipped a ton of corals in it with no problems at all.

I am tempted to write a "True Men of Genius" Song about the guy as we really really owe him.

He did a huge huge service to reefing.

But I am sure that everyone told him it was a bad idea.

In fact it was a Brilliant Idea.

Moral of the story we should not assume.

Someone mentioned Clams are Inverts yet apparantly Bayer is Safe for them.

So everyones assumtion was proven wrong.

Does that mean it is safe for Anemones - no - but maybe it is.
 
Last edited:

IF YOU HAD TO TAKE A REEFING EXAM, WOULD YOU PASS?

  • Yes!

    Votes: 32 45.7%
  • Not yet, but I have one that I want to buy in mind!

    Votes: 9 12.9%
  • No.

    Votes: 26 37.1%
  • Other (please explain).

    Votes: 3 4.3%
Back
Top