The Ecotech pump clones have arrived in Ali Express !!!

  • Thread starter Thread starter Virus
  • Start date Start date
  • Tagged users None
I believe so, yes. I'm not the holder obviously, but recall reading somewhere until 2026. Another source said it was later extended but these are both anecdotal as in I don't have a hard reference. Sorry.

Does aperture have access to legal to stop if so is the question. Maybe the juice isn't worth the squeeze.



It isn't. The other thing that is a bit concerning is that some are perfectly ok with it only because it lowers the entry price point. Some may argue it is innovation or that the original company should be innovating more.
MY question was rhetorical :beaming-face-with-smiling-eyes:

The problem with stopping it is the cost to do so.
 
I’m not jumping on or off the debate for infringement, but rather quality….
Some are saying beware of the lower quality parts, but tons of reefers use Jebao all the time. Isn’t Jacob/jebao and maybe even another name, all the same brand?
 
I’m not jumping on or off the debate for infringement, but rather quality….
Some are saying beware of the lower quality parts, but tons of reefers use Jebao all the time. Isn’t Jacob/jebao and maybe even another name, all the same brand?
All my pumps are Jebao and I've had very few problems with them. The only quality issue has been the face plate sticker falling off the controller. All other failures have been due to snails getting into the pump.
 
I agree that infringing on patents should not be encouraged, but I have always wondered if the Patent was granted out of ignorance. Induction, squirrel cage motors and the like have been around for ages. How is this functionally different from a magnetic stirrer that we've been using for at least the last 50 years?
 
I agree that infringing on patents should not be encouraged, but I have always wondered if the Patent was granted out of ignorance. Induction, squirrel cage motors and the like have been around for ages. How is this functionally different from a magnetic stirrer that we've been using for at least the last 50 years?

The patent is magnetic coupling through the glass to produce flow. Not the magnetic motor itself
 

It’s such a double edge sword. How many quality pumps have we lost out on because of this patent? Certainly Tunze or others could produce a far better product than Ecotech has. However, with no patent protection companies have no incentive to invent and innovate.
 
I agree that infringing on patents should not be encouraged, but I have always wondered if the Patent was granted out of ignorance. Induction, squirrel cage motors and the like have been around for ages. How is this functionally different from a magnetic stirrer that we've been using for at least the last 50 years?
Patents are complex, but in general the patent judge relies on prior art and research of said art to determine novelty. In most cases the actual science is above the understanding of them or the lawyers.

Whatever the case may be, truly novel or not, if the patent is issued, then it stands unless contested by prior art, etc.
 
The ecotech pump clones have arrived
Ali Express

Capture d’écran 2024-09-22 102606.png
I hope it does not cause as many problems as the original EcoTech wave motor. Two Ecotech Mp10-40 wave motors have failed in 4-5 years.
 
So is every magnetic stirrer infringing on their patent, since they're coupled through glass?
Maybe - maybe not. You have to read what they patented, look at the prior art and take your chances if you want to infringe.

Likewise, you are free to go find something that is infringed on daily, purchase the patent or partner with the holder and go sue everyone for infringement.... happens all day every day. Sometimes for good cause, other times to feed the patent trolls.

IBM is the the largest patent troll on planet earth. They buy patents by the boatload and then go search for people to coerce into licensing or being sued for infringement...

So yes, it is possible that a "magnetic" stirrer could be a infringement, but not likely, as what ecotech patented was likely the novelty of spinning a water pump through glass via the magnetic coupling and other specific mechanisms with no prior art.
 
Obviously a completely different product... It is Bluetooth...
I do not know the specifics of the patents echotech owns, but magdrives have been around for a while now.
I am too lazy to read the patents on the product, but assume there are several novel claims regarding the drive mechanism, control and mechanics of each half.

I assume you were being tongue in cheek... but the vortechs use BLE (bluetooth) to talk to each other and the controller (if you have one).
 
Patents are complex, but in general the patent judge relies on prior art and research of said art to determine novelty. In most cases the actual science is above the understanding of them or the lawyers.

Whatever the case may be, truly novel or not, if the patent is issued, then it stands unless contested by prior art, etc.
Yes, I totally agree. Lawyers and judges cannot expected to be subject matter experts on everything, but companies use this to push through patents understanding that it can be expensive to challenge in a niche industry. Ecotech makes the claim, and then it's on anyone else to spend money and hire lawyers to challenge that claim.

Are they creating flow for the aquarium?

This is almost entirely irrelevant if you actually bother to look at their patent.


They do not specify "for an aquarium" and it would be unlikely that something would be patentable just "for aquariums" if it was functionally identical to something else. Like you cannot design a pump for vegetable oil and then claim it's patentable because it's "for vegetable oil."
 
From what I’ve seen from MP users, the originals are far from bombproof (which they should be for the money - my 20 year old Tunze 6100’s are still going strong).
If manufacturers are going to expect people to not be tempted by cheap knock offs then they need to make sure their quality is next level…
 

IF YOU HAD TO TAKE A REEFING EXAM, WOULD YOU PASS?

  • Yes!

    Votes: 32 45.7%
  • Not yet, but I have one that I want to buy in mind!

    Votes: 9 12.9%
  • No.

    Votes: 26 37.1%
  • Other (please explain).

    Votes: 3 4.3%
Back
Top