The Great WD SPS Debate - Battle ZONE!

Status
Not open for further replies.
@Gonzo

Where are yeee... thoughts on my frag?
I'll give you my thoughts...

Looking at the pic, I would assume that the coral was tan with lime green polyps. I say this because I would have to assume that all things blue are in reality tan as that is the color of the average frag plug. Am I correct? :) Just kidding!

Definitely no way to identify that frag from that picture!
 
Last edited:
I'll give you my thoughts...

Looking at the pic, I would assume that the coral was tan with lime green polyps. I say this because I would have to assume that all things blue are in reality tan as that is the color of the average frag plug. Am I correct? :) Just kidding!

Definitely no way to identify that frag from that picture!

I wish I could take a better picture but I just can't seem to ever get one that is decent. I used to have a nice Tamron macro lens but sold it for more coral.

The tips of the WD are blue with the sockets and polyps being a very vibrant orange/yellowish/lime green. My base seems to be changing at the moment with the encrusting.
 
I wish I could take a better picture but I just can't seem to ever get one that is decent. I used to have a nice Tamron macro lens but sold it for more coral.
The mark of a true addict...we may need an intervention over here... :-)
 
With this coral, people already make up their mind, it's not worth the time to talk about it. It almost like getting pro-life individual to become pro-choice....not going to happen anytime soon.

I enjoy photography, I have an advance DSLR camera, but it is not easy taking coral picture under blue led...hint less picture out there for this coral.

I got a frag of WD, is it like the mother colony?!? No. But the polyp are bright yellow, body is blue/green, and I like it a lot. It too small of a frag to have all the color. Am I upset it's not mother colony color? No. It a small frag. Hope it will grow into the color.

As for the price, I got it much cheaper than the $450-800 price tag. But can you fault someone for taking $600 for a frag when people are willing to paid it? Are you telling me if gonzo, WWC, JF have a piece that people will paid $600 for...they will turn down the money and sell it for $75?
ImageUploadedByREEF2REEF1442450155.249272.jpg

I have a piece of that too. Paid much less than that. Just have to find deals.
 
My WD is still in the process of getting the right color, I hope but if I get sick and tired of it, it just has to go.
Same I did with the other hyped up SPS, never ever saw the colors coming in as I was hoping for so that one left the Diesel tank that simple!
I do care about this hobby as a hobby not who has the hype corals.
I bought and received from well known vendors unknown corals and some of them turned into some nice corals, I can honestly say better looking than the WD (in my tank) and the other one that was hyped up so much.
Will give it some time but I have already some super nice SPS lined up in the 10 SQFT frag system to replace it and some one else can try to get the colors boosted on the WD, again that simple.

This highlights something that I don't think people talk about enough in this hobby and that is that corals frequently morph their colors in different systems. Water quality, flow, lighting, nutrients, etc all play a role in color development and can all be responsible for causing a color change in that highly sought after piece. Just because you get a piece from a good vendor or private collector that you know has the right lineage and had awesome color in their system, doesn't mean that coral is going to display its best colors in your system. That's one reason I've stopped buying the expensive stuff. I've also been pleasantly surprised with other non-named corals that end up morphing into something stunning in my tank. One of my best looking colonies is a piece that I got for free from a wild colony my LFS had. It has shifted colors multiple times in my tank, but now its displaying a greyish blue body, red coloralites, and silvery white polyps and looks awesome! I guess my point is, don't get too obsessed with the expenisve named pieces. Sometimes they can be disappointing.
 
This highlights something that I don't think people talk about enough in this hobby and that is that corals frequently morph their colors in different systems. Water quality, flow, lighting, nutrients, etc all play a role in color development and can all be responsible for causing a color change in that highly sought after piece. Just because you get a piece from a good vendor or private collector that you know has the right lineage and had awesome color in their system, doesn't mean that coral is going to display its best colors in your system. That's one reason I've stopped buying the expensive stuff. I've also been pleasantly surprised with other non-named corals that end up morphing into something stunning in my tank. One of my best looking colonies is a piece that I got for free from a wild colony my LFS had. It has shifted colors multiple times in my tank, but now its displaying a greyish blue body, red coloralites, and silvery white polyps and looks awesome! I guess my point is, don't get too obsessed with the expenisve named pieces. Sometimes they can be disappointing.

Nothing new but c'mon you think that there ever will be a WD as the original colony that............ well never mind!
Points are made and discussion is going round and round and one day this thread will be dead thread as many other hyped up coral discussions.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

IF YOU HAD TO TAKE A REEFING EXAM, WOULD YOU PASS?

  • Yes!

    Votes: 32 45.7%
  • Not yet, but I have one that I want to buy in mind!

    Votes: 9 12.9%
  • No.

    Votes: 26 37.1%
  • Other (please explain).

    Votes: 3 4.3%
Back
Top