Using Flatworm Exit
- Thread starter TheEngineer
- Start date
- Tagged users None
Not definitely eaten sometimes they pull them in like that. Next week those same skirts may look perfectly fine. IME zoa nudi feed on the trunks not the skirts and the zoas will shrink sometimes still staying open but sometimes closing up too. Best to look in the dark with a flash light to find them.
To me this looks like perhaps it got nipped by a fish or crab. I have some in one of my tanks its happening very similar and I'm suspecting my sarraggasm trigger took a taste sample.
Also I found Flatworm exit to be the best killer of the nudi's but it took high doses like 4 times the level the directions call for. Tough to do in tank at that dose it will cause problems.
IMO if you think you have nudi's I would only suggest a wrasse, however I have had zero luck with the usual suggested wrasses and I have had a TON. My suggestions for pest controlling wrasse are
1. Dusky
2. Lightning wrasse (caribbean)
3. Green coris - but this guy gets huge and may or may not eat CUC and Shrimp. That said I have a 7 incher who does not eat CUC or shrimp. Even have a newly added harley that he ignores completely.
Hope that helps.
To me this looks like perhaps it got nipped by a fish or crab. I have some in one of my tanks its happening very similar and I'm suspecting my sarraggasm trigger took a taste sample.
Also I found Flatworm exit to be the best killer of the nudi's but it took high doses like 4 times the level the directions call for. Tough to do in tank at that dose it will cause problems.
IMO if you think you have nudi's I would only suggest a wrasse, however I have had zero luck with the usual suggested wrasses and I have had a TON. My suggestions for pest controlling wrasse are
1. Dusky
2. Lightning wrasse (caribbean)
3. Green coris - but this guy gets huge and may or may not eat CUC and Shrimp. That said I have a 7 incher who does not eat CUC or shrimp. Even have a newly added harley that he ignores completely.
Hope that helps.
Sabellafella
7500 Club Member
Excellence Award
Reef Tank 365
Reef Of The Month
Reef Squad Emeritus
Reef Master
My Tank Thread
My Aquarium Showcase
- Joined
- Jul 8, 2015
- Messages
- 7,593
- Reaction score
- 12,048
Yep thats a zoa nudi, why dont you dip the zoas in some peroxide? Or heavy on the iodine theyll come right offEggs and brown nudi
thats not the OP just someone providing an example photo
DereksReef77
Active Member
So you would use interceptor to kill zoanthid eating spiders? I did not know that.
I need to get a better lens, badly. Here's the best I can do, I can only get up to 55mm with the lenses I have. I think you can tell which one appears to have been chewed on. That's open and missing all of the lashes.
OOOOHH!!! A little closer look I found your problem.... Theres a bunch of tiny aptasia around those zoas buddy. They are getting whacked. Gotta take care of those. Get some berghias.
OP
OP
TheEngineer
Formerly icecool2
I'm overrun by aiptasia in the tank. They're everywhere. I tried berghia but they didn't help and I'm convinced they died. I thought aiptasia at one point. This is also happening to a colony that doesn't have aiptasia near it too though. The aiptasia problem isn't new too. I've been considering getting a couple peppermint shrimp.
OP
OP
TheEngineer
Formerly icecool2
I've looked at night and didn't see anything. I pulled one colony and checked it thoroughly. No nudis that I saw and definitely no eggs. I've seen them before. I only have a clown fish and I don't think she's ever nipped a coral. Only crabs are a couple hermits.
OP
OP
TheEngineer
Formerly icecool2
I snapped some pictures just now in the dark. I don't see anything on them, just aiptasia and a spaghetti worm. The sunny d's have gotten significantly worse since yesterday.
Last edited:
Sometimes the aptasia are really hard to see. Check the other colony that you say doesn't have aptasia. Check with a macro lens, and I bet you find some tiny ones where the zoas are irritated. Check multiple times too because of they happened to be tucked into their little hidy hole at the time your checking you'll never see them.
Some zoas will tolerate aptasia for a while but eventually aptasia will win.
About the berghia, so you have any wrasse or peppermint shrimp already in the tank? Those are the main berghia preditors. How many did you start with? How big is the tank? What kind of fish do you have?
Only option for them is
Filefish - didn't work for me & might eat your corals.
Butterfly - maybe worked for me but still have them in the system and they pop up now and then but never get big. I assume the Butterfly just doesn't see the tiny ones.
Peppermint shrimp - almost always don't work but try from different vendors might get lucky eventually. Never worked for me to the point of eradication.
Berghias - have to work but have to start with the right amount which is expensive. Didn't work for me as i have too many berghia predators, didn't start with enough, and started them in the wrong place.
Definitely they look like they are getting zapped to me. I been through the same. Especially in my frag tank. In there i just pull a plug and cover the ap with glue. But that won't work for you. Sorry for your trouble man i know it's frustrating. 
jsker
Reefing is all about the adventure
Just my 2 cents, I used a matted file fish and he eliminated the aptasia problem in two weeks.
What else to you have in the tank, had another inhabitant gone rogue.?
I have red that most have success with the flatworm exit. I was doing some reading this week using another product for the makers of flatworm exit and only one gripe.
Course of action: teat the tank with the flatworm exit, it can not hurt anything at this point. Get a Matted file fish for the aptasia
OP
OP
TheEngineer
Formerly icecool2
Only fish is a clown. Two hermits and a few astrae. I bought 10 berghias. I saw them for a couple days and then I've been unable to find any of them again.
I have a clam, so butterfly fish are out. I've thought about the filefish but I only have a 50g tank. Not to mention my QT is already in use so new fish will have to wait.
I've thought about biting the bullet and buying a laser too but I'd rather not.
I have a clam, so butterfly fish are out. I've thought about the filefish but I only have a 50g tank. Not to mention my QT is already in use so new fish will have to wait.
I've thought about biting the bullet and buying a laser too but I'd rather not.
@jsker that makes me want another try with the filefish. The one i had was ora tank bred so maybe that's why mine didn't work.
Has yours gone after anything he's not supposed to?
Has yours gone after anything he's not supposed to?
jsker
Reefing is all about the adventure
No
he is happy
He even eats the nori now with the tanys. Just look at ORA and the matted filefish is new to them. Mine is real dosel and comes to the front of the tank when I come into the room. I have had him for a year. In the past year I have had a aptasia pop up and a day or so later the aptasia is gone. I do feed frozen in small amount twice a day.
