What is the safe upper limit of PH

  • Thread starter Thread starter GAMGAM
  • Start date Start date
  • Tagged users None
I think you all are too focused on discounting the PH number. With the recirculating co2 scrubber, the 2L of kalkwasser, the soda ash, and the stupid algae anyone could have high PH, but where is the danger with high stable PH.
 
To try to smooth the overnight low.
Gotcha. I wouldn't be worrying about that right now. You're already ahead of the pH game with the scrubber media. Adding kalk seems like a hat on a hat at this stage in your tanks maturity.

Dosing kalk at night only invites more issues.
 
Even with a perfect scenario with an atmospheric content of CO2 of 300 your results are not attainable.
 
Screenshot_20230215_005201_Chrome.png

I believe (from my limited understanding and reading) you would see precipitation at those values... I could be wrong of course (probably lol)

 
I think you all are too focused on discounting the PH number. With the recirculating co2 scrubber, the 2L of kalkwasser, the soda ash, and the stupid algae anyone could have high PH, but where is the danger with high stable PH.
Understandably you want these numbers to be accurate. You are taking a lot of steps to limit CO2 and raise pH. You are not doing that much. You can only do so much before you reach equilibrium with the atmosphere.
 
I think 8.6 is as high as you should push it. I think it also helps to have a good device to measure pH levels. I’m using Reeffactory’s pH probe monitor and am pushing 8.5-8.6 by the end of photoperiod. It’s really good to be able to track with their monitor over the day to see where I can improve. I noticed a dip over night so increased my refugium lighting to help balance ph swings. Can see happier corals as a result.
 
Ok I calibrated the probe. It went from 8.70 to 8.55. Pretty close. I realize it’s logarithmic but not off by a mile
 
but where is the danger with high stable PH.
There's no simple answer to this. A pH spike is one thing, but maintaining it at elevated levels above natural seawater is not recommended. There are people that sustainably run their pH at higher levels. My buddy used to run his at 8.6 without issues but that's not for the novice.

At that point you're sitting on the razors edge. I used to run mine at 8.45 and now I leveled off at 8.30.

From experience and others testimony, going above 8.30 doesn't seem to yeild any major benefits.

And just so you know that I'm not blowing smoke here's a recent photo of the right side of my tank

20230126_161217.jpg
 
Ok I calibrated the probe. It went from 8.70 to 8.55. Pretty close.
I’m in the same boat following beacaue I want to know the answer aswell. My ph hits about 8.62 and low of 8.4 at night. What is to high. But again could be testing error for me
 
There's no simple answer to this. A pH spike is one thing, but maintaining it at elevated levels above natural seawater is not recommended. There are people that sustainably run their pH at higher levels. My buddy used to run his at 8.6 without issues but that's not for the novice.

At that point you're sitting on the razors edge. I used to run mine at 8.45 and now I leveled off at 8.30.

From experience and others testimony, going above 8.30 doesn't seem to yeild any major benefits.

And just so you know that I'm not blowing smoke here's a recent photo of the right side of my tank

20230126_161217.jpg
Tell that tang to move out the way :)
 
I’m not trying to push it out to a rediculos number for the sake of setting a high score. But I think there is a value in having a reasonably high ph and work towards this. But have a hard time finding data about the upper limit.
 
I do have an erv installed on my house and huge outside air ran to skimmer
Im jealous!

I hit 8.2 at peak and I have about 1 gal per day kalkwasser and 80ml of soda ash a day.

Im lucky it stays above 7.90 before lights on, i also run a scrubber with 1kg media, open windows, and run a fuge that makes about a .8ph bump.

7 people in a house will do that though.... a small one... with pets.
 
Now you guys got me thinking is my ph way to high along with way to large of a daily swing of .3
 
Im jealous!

I hit 8.2 at peak and I have about 1 gal per day kalkwasser and 80ml of soda ash a day.

Im lucky it stays above 7.90 before lights on, i also run a scrubber with 1kg media, open windows, and run a fuge that makes about a .8ph bump.

7 people in a house will do that though.... a small one... with pets.
I have small house about 900 sqft with 4 of us and pets co2 was horrible and was going thru co2 media like crazy 60$ a month on 400 gallon system. looked into erv was skeptical on if it would work I read a few reviews of people on here who were praising them for the CO2 removal and pH gains when I priced it my contractor wanted $4000 installed. I bought it myself for about 1600 and took me three weekends total and did it myself. Literally one of the best things I ever did for my reef system on top of that me and my family are breathing cleaner, fresh air, win-win, if you ask me.
 
I think 8.6 is as high as you should push it. I think it also helps to have a good device to measure pH levels. I’m using Reeffactory’s pH probe monitor and am pushing 8.5-8.6 by the end of photoperiod. It’s really good to be able to track with their monitor over the day to see where I can improve. I noticed a dip over night so increased my refugium lighting to help balance ph swings. Can see happier corals as a result.
I like this answer and agree with it. I’m not trying to go crazy. I’m guessing my numbers are similar to yours in the 8.6’s. That seems good. Like ideal. I was really getting worried about it and was thinking about shutting off my skimmer with a ph controller to limit my ph. Now it’s just high. That’s good I think. Lol
 

IF YOU HAD TO TAKE A REEFING EXAM, WOULD YOU PASS?

  • Yes!

    Votes: 30 44.8%
  • Not yet, but I have one that I want to buy in mind!

    Votes: 9 13.4%
  • No.

    Votes: 25 37.3%
  • Other (please explain).

    Votes: 3 4.5%
Back
Top