What is the safe upper limit of PH

  • Thread starter Thread starter GAMGAM
  • Start date Start date
  • Tagged users None
Take your readings with a grain of salt. Most pH probes are only accurate to about +/-0.2 in my opinion and most don't publish their accuracy. GHL claims +/-0.1 accuracy, but this may only be true in ideal laboratory conditions with a freshly professionally calibrated probe.
 
Take your readings with a grain of salt. Most pH probes are only accurate to about +/-0.2 in my opinion and most don't publish their accuracy. GHL claims +/-0.1 accuracy, but this may only be true in ideal laboratory conditions with a freshly professionally calibrated probe.
True, but +- means it could be actually higher then it says. I calibrated the probe with fresh liquid so it should be pretty close.

I did like the pun. Lol
 
I do not know if your pH is accurate, but if it is, more aeration with normal or higher CO2 air will reduce it.

The primary "risk" from elevated pH is increased precipitation of calcium carbonate on sand (hardening it), and on pumps, heaters, and anything else warm.

Some photosynthetic organisms, such as some macroalgae, use CO2 and those may suffer if pH is too high. I discuss that issue here:

Photosynthesis and the Reef Aquarium, Part I: Carbon Sources by Randy Holmes-Farley - Reefkeeping.com


Relative rates of photosynthesis in seawater (measured by oxygen evolution) at pH 8.7 relative to pH 8.0. A value of 100 means that the rates were the same, and values below 100 indicate less photosynthesis at pH 8.7.

​
​
Species of macroalgae:
Relative photosynthesis at pH 8.7 compared to pH 8.1 (as a %):​
Chaetomorpha aerea
75​
Cladophora rupestris
100​
Enteromorpha compressa
67​
Ulva rigida
100​
Codium fragile
76​
Asparagopsis armata
45​
Gelidium pusillum
33​
Gelidium sesquipedale
18​
Gymnogongrus sp.
39​
Osmunda pinnatifida
46​
Porphyra leucosticta
110​
Fucus spiralis
86​
Colpomenia sinuosa
100​
Dictyota dichotoma
53​
Cystoseira tamariscifolia
57​
Padina pavonia
53​
Thanks for the reply Randy, that was an interesting article. Do we know much about the upper PH limit of some of the more common corals we keep (acropora, euphillia, gonipora).

you were right. My probe was reading about 0.15 high so i was only around 8.6- 8.65 at the peak (which is probably perfect) and not really in the danger zone.

I’ve had a hard time finding people who have had negative outcomes from intentionally and carefully increasing their PH (with an acceptable alk). I’ve heard of high PH “events” doing damage (say a kalk overdose) but never someone who was carefully pushing the edge, maybe that’s what Sean was alluding to is that you just can’t physically get it up their safely, and more importantly is there any benefit to doing so.
 
Last edited:
Thanks for the reply Randy, that was an interesting article. Do we know much about the upper PH limit of some of the more common corals we keep (acropora, euphillia, gonipora).

you were right. My probe was reading about 0.15 high so i was only around 8.6- 8.65 at the peak (which is probably perfect) and not really in the danger zone.

I’ve had a hard time finding people who have had negative outcomes from intentionally and carefully increasing their PH (with an acceptable alk). I’ve heard of high PH “events” doing damage (say a kalk overdose) but never someone who was carefully pushing the edge, maybe that’s what Sean was alluding to is that you just can’t physically get it up their safely, and more importantly is there any benefit to doing so.

The only thing I recall seeing studied in corals as a function of pH is calcification rate, not photosynthesis.

Reports of precipitation events (excessive demand for alk and calcium) are very common, and stopping pH boosting procedures (such as a CO2 scrubber, kalkwasser, etc.) are among the main things I recommend.

Here's a typical post of mine:

Once a calcium carbonate precipitation event is initiated (due to high alk and pH, for example), you need to break the cycle because the surfaces of any precipitate act as good seed crystals for more precipitation until something gets onto those surfaces and blocks further precipitation.

Here's my generic advice for such scenarios:

1. Stop all efforts to boost pH.
2. Stop dosing alk for a bit and let it decline.
3. Reduce pH by switching to a low pH alk mix like sodium bicarbonate, or a calcium organic such as Tropic Marin All for Reef.
4. Ensure magnesium is normal to high.
5. Keep organics and phosphate on the high side.

After a few days of not dosing alk, restart slowly, adding additives to a very high flow area so it mixes in fast.
 
Can you link the pH probe on here? Based off your first picture I think I have the same unit as you. Not only do these probes go out of calibration quickly but the probes themselves also go bad. If you have the same one I have. Mine currently reads 8.8, but when I first set it up it read 8.3. How long have you been using it for?
 
I travel alot for work so my house is regularly closed up for about a week at a time. after 3-4 days my PH seems to hit a "cap" at 8.55...it has consistently flatlined there as a max for the past 6 months when im gone.
 
Update

AEACDA3D-EDAC-409A-8AF8-F4E707CC4B00.png
E33487A9-1419-4C75-B60B-73471102F4F5.png


Ph still super high, have added a HRV to maintain about 410ppm of C02 in the house, pumping 10L of kalk, 700ml of soda ash (at 35 tsp per 5 gallons for concentration), recirculating C02 scrubber, and by adding an auto water change of 8.1L per day bumped it up to 8.8 (calibrated apex probe). Think this is possible.

Can see the growth from the pic on page 1.

9BF0D166-FEBD-4B15-A3CF-5DAF9B0F42FB.jpeg
 
Last edited:
More then likely your probe is sketch, it’s been my experience dosing sodium hydroxide and calcium hydroxide that 8.6 you will start having precipitation on your pumps, ie they lock up and stop working. You will also notice buildup on your heater. Those are the issues that will stop you from red lining ph, coral seems to be resilient.

I believe the ph you have is obtainable but only if you have a tank full of coral, sodium hydroxide, and no skimmer to input c02 into
water.

I’d test probe, first by removing tank water and setting it in a plastic cup outside your sump(apex ph sometimes gets jacked up by stray electric), and then with calibration packs, the small single use ones, not the jars that get contaminated after repeated uses.
 
More then likely your probe is sketch, it’s been my experience dosing sodium hydroxide and calcium hydroxide that 8.6 you will start having precipitation on your pumps, ie they lock up and stop working. You will also notice buildup on your heater. Those are the issues that will stop you from red lining ph, coral seems to be resilient.

I believe the ph you have is obtainable but only if you have a tank full of coral, sodium hydroxide, and no skimmer to input c02 into
water.

I’d test probe, first by removing tank water and setting it in a plastic cup outside your sump(apex ph sometimes gets jacked up by stray electric), and then with calibration packs, the small single use ones, not the jars that get contaminated after repeated uses.
Probe is only a few months old and calibrated with individual packs. Skimmer has a recirculating C02 reactor on it, it removes C02 from the water. I do have sodium hydroxide but never did bother trying it. The soda ash works good to fine tune alk after 10L of kalk a day. Tank has a pretty large alk demand with my coral load.

Heater never really runs. Haven’t had precipitation problems as far as mechanical breakdowns. I do have plating coraline that grows so fast it’s pretty much invasive and can grow over the acros.

All the high ph means is I am stripping out the C02 to super low levels. The corals seem to be growing faster and super healthy with great Color. I didn’t expect the auto water change to raise ph but it has, alk demand has increased with it as its dropped from 8.5 to 8.

I have been toying with taking the c02 scrubber offline as the ph is very high but aside from potential precipitation has anyone seen their acropora struggle due to excessively high but stable Ph
 
Last edited:
Out of curiosity, how many gallons is this tank?

I can see you have a lot of coral, but they haven’t grown in yet, honestly surprised to hear the ph levels you’re hitting.

I did not notice growth substantially increase when pegging ph at 8.5 vs 8.3. The precip events made me give up the 8.5 and beyond experiments; pump maintenance and wear and tear were not worth it.
 
It’s 200 gallons total(Red Sea Reefer 750). It’s been running for about a year and a half as is. Some of the faster growing pieces (pink Cadillac and Bali green slimer) are getting pretty big. I’ll post a better pic.

If I was having precip events I’d back it off but haven’t had any problems. My main issue seems to be coraline being pretty much out of control.
 
So that pic is from January 12 and here is a shot of the green slimer right now(lights are pretty blue this time of night). Can see the growth in the last month.

7A4352BF-5607-443C-8020-44CF84842017.jpeg
 

IF YOU HAD TO TAKE A REEFING EXAM, WOULD YOU PASS?

  • Yes!

    Votes: 30 44.8%
  • Not yet, but I have one that I want to buy in mind!

    Votes: 9 13.4%
  • No.

    Votes: 25 37.3%
  • Other (please explain).

    Votes: 3 4.5%
Back
Top