What is this? Tank worse than ever.

  • Thread starter Thread starter Wxguy23
  • Start date Start date
  • Tagged users None
How do you know when they are dying? I don’t see “more” but still stringy junk on my rocks. Do I just scrub it off??
 
Dinoflagellates that do not enter the water column at night are a slow process to remove. There is no real short cut. You remove, the next day they mulitply to the same exact numbers. Follow the course of action that @saltyhog laid out. Dinos need weeks of optimal levels to suddenly “bloom” this window can be the quick remedy period. Once they have bloomed, in most cases is a several week cure timeline. Increasing biodiversity throughout this period can decrease by a little bit of time. (Bacteria, pods, other microfauna) As a benefit to other algae though when its gone its gone there is no clean up of dead algae.

DO NOT USE ph increasing and decreasing products. If need to increase ph, like doing a fw dip to match dt use an alkalinity adjustment like bicarbonate, a calibrated ph meter and an air stone. Dont increase an entire aquarium though.
 
I’m seeing less and less. But at the end of the day, more bubbles are returning. The battle continues.

Nitrates are still low. Should I turn off skimmer?
 
Nevermind. After Turing lights back to 50% for 3 days my tank is covered.

After spending $$$$ on lights, stand, uv, new skimmer, my tank looks worse than ever.
I did all that was written. Black out, H2O2 for 2 weeks now, increasing doses, raised PH to 8.8
And turkey blasted almost daily and removed rocks and cleaned.

I think I’ve learned my lesson. Tank was good for 2 years. Now embarrassing. Time to find another hobby.
 
Yo chief, don't give up. These things happen. I can tell you without a doubt unless your water is coming out 0 tds you are having these issues because you use tap water. Your testing low on nutrients because the Dino's are consuming them.
 
Wx

before you stop can I get a chance at it, I would have arranged a few things differently above, we have a decent backround on brink tanks post a pic
 
Yo chief, don't give up. These things happen. I can tell you without a doubt unless your water is coming out 0 tds you are having these issues because you use tap water. Your testing low on nutrients because the Dino's are consuming them.

I just Turkey blasted rocks 2 hours ago and dosed with H202. Rocks were almost bare. In 2 hours, I’ve got more bubbles.

Should I turn off my skimmer and feed like crazy now?

As for water. I get that. I have used same water for over two years. I can’t now buy a RODI unit after just dropping $700. Wife says to sell it.

image.jpg


image.jpg
 
Dude don’t throw in the towel. You don’t have to buy an RODI unit. There are other options. You can buy distilled water from the store or go to a LFS and get RODI from them. Some of them give it away free. I will say though, one of the biggest turning points of my success was when I stopped using tap water and employed a float valve for an ATO. Totally changed my experience. That was ten years ago and I’ve ran into other battles along the way, each battle won though is so rewarding.

This is an expensive hobby and it’s hard to watch and is so stressful when things start to go south. You said you were successful for two years , most likely it’s just a few tweaks to your husbandry and you’ll be back in business. And getting the Dino’s in check... but you can kick it man
 
My dinos took months to go away.
What i did, some of this is from the big dino thread some was my take on what it wanted to accomplish.

First i got dinos from using bio pellets and my po4 dropping to zero.
First step started dosing nutrients. Po4 and no3 using NaNO3 and KH2PO4.
Installed a small jebao uv.
Next part was how i decided to jumpstart competition.
-started a 20 gallon tank, i live on the ocean so, took a few cups of bay mud, ocean sand, and rocks. Through this in the “bio tank” with a kessil h80 providing light each week dosed about 3x the silica levels of nsw(over 3 days as this does effect ph when using NaSi.
-Brought nutrients in this tank to
25ppm NO3, .2 PO4 and K 450ppm.
-Added ulva and chaeto on week 3.

Let this tank run for 45 days. Added the non silica rocks to the DT as well as brought up the silica levels though at a much decreased rate.

-added a bag o bugs and 3 different pod cultures to the DT.

-had a short lived diatom bloom(as intended) dinoflagellates receded about the same day. Also had an ulva breakout. This i got rid of with a little pruning and adding a dwarf angel.

I don’t actually know what worked for me as i added a lot of life at once. But with this still took 2-3 months before i was dino free.
 
My dinos took months to go away.
What i did, some of this is from the big dino thread some was my take on what it wanted to accomplish.

First i got dinos from using bio pellets and my po4 dropping to zero.
First step started dosing nutrients. Po4 and no3 using NaNO3 and KH2PO4.
Installed a small jebao uv.
Next part was how i decided to jumpstart competition.
-started a 20 gallon tank, i live on the ocean so, took a few cups of bay mud, ocean sand, and rocks. Through this in the “bio tank” with a kessil h80 providing light each week dosed about 3x the silica levels of nsw(over 3 days as this does effect ph when using NaSi.
-Brought nutrients in this tank to
25ppm NO3, .2 PO4 and K 450ppm.
-Added ulva and chaeto on week 3.

Let this tank run for 45 days. Added the non silica rocks to the DT as well as brought up the silica levels though at a much decreased rate.

-added a bag o bugs and 3 different pod cultures to the DT.

-had a short lived diatom bloom(as intended) dinoflagellates receded about the same day. Also had an ulva breakout. This i got rid of with a little pruning and adding a dwarf angel.

I don’t actually know what worked for me as i added a lot of life at once. But with this still took 2-3 months before i was dino free.
Wow. Have to read up on some of this, as I don’t know what a few of these things are.
 
Okay, treated with MacroBacter7.
I now have more than ever. After 2 weeks it looks much worse despite an entire bottle.

I’ve done almost everything else. I’ve had a UV going with new bulb for a month. I blow this crap off 2-3 times a day.

Barely run lights now for more than 3-4 hours. Or Dino takes over.

I’ve lost my two corals. Most of my CUC.

I’ve checked all water. I’ve got the best water I’ve EVER had. I’m trying to raise Nitrates but this crap is eating it all up.

I’ve done most of what everyone has suggested.

Options.
Pods
Dino X
Start over (quit).

This isn’t fun.
Have you tried Dino X?
 
How are you trying to raise nitrate? What is your phosphate now? Organic nitrate and phosphate seem to sometimes worsen them. Did you go to/read the thread I posted earlier? The best and easiest way to raise nitrates is sodium nitrate (food or reagent grade). Here is a very inexpensive source. https://www.amazon.com/gp/product/B0190TOJUS/ref=ppx_yo_dt_b_asin_title_o05_s00?ie=UTF8&psc=1

I dissolved 1 tablespoon in 200 cc of RO/DI and started with 5cc in my 155 gallon DT.

For Phosphate SeaChem Flourish is easy and inexpensive. It is available at most aquarium places but also on Amazon.
 
As an Amazon Associate we earn from qualifying purchases.
How are you trying to raise nitrate? What is your phosphate now? Organic nitrate and phosphate seem to sometimes worsen them. Did you go to/read the thread I posted earlier? The best and easiest way to raise nitrates is sodium nitrate (food or reagent grade). Here is a very inexpensive source. https://www.amazon.com/gp/product/B0190TOJUS/ref=ppx_yo_dt_b_asin_title_o05_s00?ie=UTF8&psc=1

I dissolved 1 tablespoon in 200 cc of RO/DI and started with 5cc in my 155 gallon DT.

For Phosphate SeaChem Flourish is easy and inexpensive. It is available at most aquarium places but also on Amazon.

Over feeding mostly.
Phosphate is 0.25-.50

I read pages of the link you gave me. Good ideas. Some I can’t do as I only have a HOB and HOB skimmer.
 
As an Amazon Associate we earn from qualifying purchases.
Your problem isn't going to get better till you get nitrates and phosphates up. Again, don't try to do it by over feeding. Organic nitrate/phosphate are likely not only to not help but to make the problem worse.
 
I would slowly ramp your lights back to normal.
Black out or photoperiod reduction is like putting a piece of scotch tape on a leaking pipe, looks like its fixing it till the scotch tape comes off. They reproduce faster with light but can maintain themselves through engulfing other microorganisms. Cyano reduction methods will not work with dinos.

Your tank will look ugly but no need to stress corals any further.

@saltyhog the no3 supplement and the seachem po4 one will help. I like dry kh2po4 because allows use of a calculator like this. https://rotalabutterfly.com/nutrient-calculator.php
Use a scale that will measure .01 grams And a graduated cylinder.

Dose enough each day to reach .1 po4 then test 24 hours after first dose see where you are and adjust. Po4 is trickier than no3 to raise thanks to the aragonite in our tanks. No3 pick any threshold you can test for with your test kit thats under say 10ppm. I also like sodium silicate, but dose low on this as will effect ph. This will help diatoms bloom. Which will outcompete dinos once there is not a low nutrient issue.

Go slow, your tank will recover [emoji4]
 
Do I turn off my skimmer?
Do I remove my bag phosguard that prevents silica?

Do I add anymore bacteria? I have a bottle of dr Tim’s eco balance.

What about adding Nori sheets?
 
Last edited:
Leave the skimmer on

Take out the phosgaurd its eating your phosphate too.

You can stop dosing bacteria.

Only use nori if your fish are herbivores and need more algae to eat. Dont add to just add it :)
 
How are you trying to raise nitrate? What is your phosphate now? Organic nitrate and phosphate seem to sometimes worsen them. Did you go to/read the thread I posted earlier? The best and easiest way to raise nitrates is sodium nitrate (food or reagent grade). Here is a very inexpensive source. https://www.amazon.com/gp/product/B0190TOJUS/ref=ppx_yo_dt_b_asin_title_o05_s00?ie=UTF8&psc=1

I dissolved 1 tablespoon in 200 cc of RO/DI and started with 5cc in my 155 gallon DT.

For Phosphate SeaChem Flourish is easy and inexpensive. It is available at most aquarium places but also on Amazon.
Flourish or Brightwell neophos?
 
As an Amazon Associate we earn from qualifying purchases.
Leave the skimmer on

Take out the phosgaurd its eating your phosphate too.

You can stop dosing bacteria.

Only use nori if your fish are herbivores and need more algae to eat. Dont add to just add it :)
Okay. Got a yellow tang but he never touched that stuff.
 

IF YOU HAD TO TAKE A REEFING EXAM, WOULD YOU PASS?

  • Yes!

    Votes: 30 44.8%
  • Not yet, but I have one that I want to buy in mind!

    Votes: 9 13.4%
  • No.

    Votes: 25 37.3%
  • Other (please explain).

    Votes: 3 4.5%
Back
Top