Since we cannot account for proper dissection to determine cause of death, please only vote if you meet the following requirements:
1. Have used Bayer as a dip
2. Had a death(s) of a coral, fish, crab, etc, that was not directly the result of:
Some compound being dumped into the tank (ie: kids dumped bleach, food accidentally dumped, etc)
A obvious mistake on your part (ie: forgot to turn the ATO back on, refilled gfo, etc)
A hardware failure (ie: heater blew up, pump stopped, etc)
A specimen that displayed a sickness or disease prior to introduction (ie: corals that showed deterioration or missing tissue, fish that had physical damage, etc)
Please choose yes or no, and if yes, please also choose each corresponding time range. (yes I only had one death at a few months, or yes I had a death at a few months and after a couple years)
This does not prove anything directly, but it does aide our progression as a hobby.
Please give it some thought and be honest, thank you for your contribution.
It seems that the point of this poll is simply to get one of 2 conclusions:
1) Bayer might have caused tank death
2) Bayer did not cause tank death
You say not to take the poll unless you have used Bayer and had a tank death and can rule out any other cause of death except Bayer. That seems like a vary biased approach to any research.
You are also redundant in the use of "Yes" as one option and then with other "yes" options based on time frame. You could just delete the first "Yes" only option.
So, for example, you end up with these results:
YES: 400
NO: 350
WITHIN A FEW MONTHS: 100
WITHIN A COUPLE YEARS: 200
LONGER THAN COUPLE / LESS THAN 5 YEARS: 100
First, if your YES doesn't equal the three time frame answers added up, your data is skewed. Of course, some who said yes may have needed a "Longer than 5 years" option. I would have also gone for more exact time frames (1 to 6 months, 6 months to 1 year, 1 year to 2 years, 2 years to 5 year, 5 years or more). That would have covered all time options.
But what does that example data tells us that is REALLY useful? Honestly, not much. It tells us the answer to what was asked, but I don't see how any conclusions can be drawn from it. The conclusions, based on the survey, can be easily foretold:
- some people have used Bayer and had things die
- some people have used Bayer and not had things die
- some people don't use Bayer
But none of these numbers can be used to draw any conclusions on the use of Bayer and its relation to saltwater deaths.
In essence, the survey gives us data. But data with no basis of interpretation. And without that basis, it is useless. It's just numbers.