Within 5 years of using Bayer dip, had a death?

Have you had a death in your tank within 5 years of using Bayer? (read guidelines for vote first)

  • Yes

    Votes: 6 13.0%
  • No

    Votes: 23 50.0%
  • Within a few months, a death occurred

    Votes: 6 13.0%
  • Within a couple years, a death occurred

    Votes: 0 0.0%
  • Longer than a couple years, less than five

    Votes: 0 0.0%
  • Never used it

    Votes: 14 30.4%

  • Total voters
    46
Status
Not open for further replies.
So...if there haven't been any deaths in a system in 5 years where Bayer has been used, can we attribute that system's success entirely to the use of Bayer? :cool: I mean...if the point of the poll is to attribute any deaths occurring in a system in 5 years to the use of Bayer...:confused: I'm just trying to be sure I understand the point of this poll... :D
 
Hey Mods, any way I can edit this post still? I guess I could add a 'never used it' to allow visibility post-vote..
Added "never used it" as requested...

I do concur with those who have already stated that this poll is not ultimately going to prove or even reasonably infer anything about Bayer because of the parameters placed.
 
This thread in one image:

ZBOOWO1-00084.jpg
 
It did, and has shown at least three things.

People have reported deaths after the use of bayer, people have reported no deaths after the use of bayer, some people have not used bayer.

I'm sorry some of you do not believe it a worthwhile poll.
 
It did, and has shown at least three things.

People have reported deaths after the use of bayer, people have reported no deaths after the use of bayer, some people have not used bayer.

I'm sorry some of you do not believe it a worthwhile poll.
I don't think anyone debated either of those points.
 
It's hard to prove that dipping corals in bayer leads to death. There's other factors that we have to consider too, such as a person's tank size, flow, lighting, if they ever QT'ed, if they have maricultured pieces, aquacultured pieces, UNLS system, their parameter levels, etc etc. No one person has the same tank as the next person.

Heck, if someone created an exact same poll saying "Within 5 years of using Coral RX or ReVive, did you ever had a death", you're probably going to get similar results.
 
Anecdotal evidence is absolutely relevant and has led to life saving hypotheses and discoveries! But not all data is evidence.

Is it possible to send water samples to a lab that could detect the chemicals within Bayer and other products? Could Triton perform such tests?
 
They would detect the copper in the materials that is used for one compound, but we're not dealing with basic elements here.

I think people are confused why I made the poll.
 
Since we cannot account for proper dissection to determine cause of death, please only vote if you meet the following requirements:

1. Have used Bayer as a dip
2. Had a death(s) of a coral, fish, crab, etc, that was not directly the result of:

Some compound being dumped into the tank (ie: kids dumped bleach, food accidentally dumped, etc)
A obvious mistake on your part (ie: forgot to turn the ATO back on, refilled gfo, etc)
A hardware failure (ie: heater blew up, pump stopped, etc)
A specimen that displayed a sickness or disease prior to introduction (ie: corals that showed deterioration or missing tissue, fish that had physical damage, etc)

Please choose yes or no, and if yes, please also choose each corresponding time range. (yes I only had one death at a few months, or yes I had a death at a few months and after a couple years)

This does not prove anything directly, but it does aide our progression as a hobby.
Please give it some thought and be honest, thank you for your contribution.

It seems that the point of this poll is simply to get one of 2 conclusions:
1) Bayer might have caused tank death
2) Bayer did not cause tank death

You say not to take the poll unless you have used Bayer and had a tank death and can rule out any other cause of death except Bayer. That seems like a vary biased approach to any research.

You are also redundant in the use of "Yes" as one option and then with other "yes" options based on time frame. You could just delete the first "Yes" only option.

So, for example, you end up with these results:
YES: 400
NO: 350
WITHIN A FEW MONTHS: 100
WITHIN A COUPLE YEARS: 200
LONGER THAN COUPLE / LESS THAN 5 YEARS: 100

First, if your YES doesn't equal the three time frame answers added up, your data is skewed. Of course, some who said yes may have needed a "Longer than 5 years" option. I would have also gone for more exact time frames (1 to 6 months, 6 months to 1 year, 1 year to 2 years, 2 years to 5 year, 5 years or more). That would have covered all time options.

But what does that example data tells us that is REALLY useful? Honestly, not much. It tells us the answer to what was asked, but I don't see how any conclusions can be drawn from it. The conclusions, based on the survey, can be easily foretold:
- some people have used Bayer and had things die
- some people have used Bayer and not had things die
- some people don't use Bayer

But none of these numbers can be used to draw any conclusions on the use of Bayer and its relation to saltwater deaths.

In essence, the survey gives us data. But data with no basis of interpretation. And without that basis, it is useless. It's just numbers.
 
Last edited:
Not useless.

I've been confronted by people denying there's any deaths because of bayer, period.
I added the guidelines in an attempt to rule out anything that isn't considered a "random death".
The correlation to the use of bayer is only a small factor, but present. And the yes + time frame is what was intended...

Does this answer all questions, of course not!! But it answers more than people making assumptions. It's funny though you can see those getting angry that are probably defending the use of bayer. Just a guess. :)
 
Not useless.

I've been confronted by people denying there's any deaths because of bayer, period.
I added the guidelines in an attempt to rule out anything that isn't considered a "random death".
The correlation to the use of bayer is only a small factor, but present. And the yes + time frame is what was intended...

Does this answer all questions, of course not!! But it answers more than people making assumptions. It's funny though you can see those getting angry that are probably defending the use of bayer. Just a guess. :)


Then (and I mean this honestly, not in a confrontational way) what IS the usefulness of this data, say in my example answers scenario? 400 used Bayer w/ deaths. 350 used Bayer w/o deaths. That's just raw data - and meaningless unless we can draw conclusions from it. So what conclusions can we legitimately draw from such sample data? The only "conclusion" I see is 400 people used Bayer and had death, and 350 people used Bayer and had no death. But that's just numbers. There is no causal connection to Bayer, which seems to be the point behind (the bias of) your poll.
 
Last edited:
Not useless.
It tells us there has been deaths following bayer. Does that mean bayer caused it, that is not identified.
It tells us they have not seen deaths following bayer. Does that mean bayer is ok, that is not identified.

It tells us that bayer is not out of the scope of these deaths.

Like I said, the questions have to start somewhere for data to be gathered. To discount this poll does nothing but reinforce ignorance. (that's not a personal attack, ignorance can be innocent)

Sorry Steve, I responded but it got deleted.
 
Ok, Bayer is not out of the scope of these deaths.
Neither is the food I'm feeding, the salt I'm using, the RO water I'm making, the two-part I'm dosing, and on... and on.
I could have told you all that without poll.
 
Ok, Bayer is not out of the scope of these deaths.
Neither is the food I'm feeding, the salt I'm using, the RO water I'm making, the two-part I'm dosing, and on... and on.
I could have told you all that without poll.

I made the poll because I was told bayer does not kill corals. (others even say 'anything')

I have made my point.
 
I made the poll because I was told bayer does not kill corals. (others even say 'anything')

I have made my point.


But you haven't. Don't you see that? You are working to disprove the statement that "Bayer does not kills corals". Your survey and any collected data doesn't do that. It will merely show that Bayer was used by people who had corals die. That's it. Nothing more. No causal connection.

And as @d2mini noted - there are waaaaayyyy too many other possible variables the survey doesn't take into account to make any claim for or against the use of Bayer.
 
Last edited:
I still want to know about your vendetta towards Bayer. Why so much misguided hate?
 
I made the poll because I was told bayer does not kill corals. (others even say 'anything')

I have made my point.
Not. At. All.

This poll doesn't prove in any way that Bayer caused any of the deaths. This poll doesn't provide any data regarding any point that has been debated.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

IF YOU HAD TO TAKE A REEFING EXAM, WOULD YOU PASS?

  • Yes!

    Votes: 30 44.8%
  • Not yet, but I have one that I want to buy in mind!

    Votes: 9 13.4%
  • No.

    Votes: 25 37.3%
  • Other (please explain).

    Votes: 3 4.5%
Back
Top