Can't keep fish alive in QT

  • Thread starter Thread starter K7BMG
  • Start date Start date
  • Tagged users None
So just did a Hanna check test on Iron.
Iron Test.jpg


Triton test show's it in the red at 12 ug/l
Hard to know the truth.... Thoughts?

Also did copper API test also shows a 0
 
So just did a Hanna check test on Iron.
Iron Test.jpg


Triton test show's it in the red at 12 ug/l
Hard to know the truth.... Thoughts?

What is difference in the units of measurement?
 
I don't know the calculation but I will find out.
 
1 ug/L= .001 PPM

So just did a Hanna check test on Iron.
Iron Test.jpg


Triton test show's it in the red at 12 ug/l
Hard to know the truth.... Thoughts?

Also did copper API test also shows a 0

If Triton stated 12 ug/L then Hanna should have 0.01... I don’t know the +\- variance on the Hanna but if 0.012 is in the red then I think our tests/checkers should read with more accuracy, right?!
 
I don't know of an alternate cleaning solution other than bleach.

My protocol, adapted from homebrewing experience, and hasn't failed me yet- including tangling with Uronema:

Scrub with 3% Bleach, hot water rinse, soak in sodium percarbonate or spray with hydrogen peroxide, RODI rinse, full dry.

This will leave you residue-free and I don't think there's a microorganism out there that can survive that gauntlet.
 
It is possible that a fish has an attached trophont when collected. The problem is when they are put into an isolated system and the parasites begin to multiply.

Nothing has really changed. Which is why I'm such an advocate for prophylactic treatment.
You are totally right! Better to treat no matter what!
 
OP....are you going to be getting more fish soon? Please keep us posted on how things are going! I am sure many people can learn from experiences like yours both good and bad! Sending positive thoughts and vibes your way! [emoji16]
 
Keep in mind my shop is fed direct from the well, there seems to be some confusion on that.
The only thing between my well and the tank is my RO/DI

I missed that. Now I´m convinced that it most be a problem with your RODI because the TRITON test shows figures of different compounds that you can expect from a well where your household have the water cleaning equipment you have. My experiences with different local wells here in Sweden say that.

Does your daughters’ freshwater aquaria take water from the household or your shop?

Do not take this question as an insult (I have personally done more idiotical things than this) - you have not - by mistake - take your aquarium water from the waste drain of the RODI filter?

By the way - your Hanna checker can´t read this low concentration of iron - Hanna themselves say
  • Accuracy ±0.04 mg/L (ppm)
Triton result 12 ppt is the same as 0.012 ppm - well below the accuracy - trust TRITON

Do a iron test direct from the well - before your RODI equipment. If reading anything - do a test both from the waste and clean water from the RODI unit. Take a test from your tap in your household too - after all treatment equipment.

Sincerely Lasse
 
OP....are you going to be getting more fish soon? Please keep us posted on how things are going! I am sure many people can learn from experiences like yours both good and bad! Sending positive thoughts and vibes your way! [emoji16]

Yes I will be getting more fish, the when is the question.
But I will try to keep updated.
 
I missed that. Now I´m convinced that it most be a problem with your RODI because the TRITON test shows figures of different compounds that you can expect from a well where your household have the water cleaning equipment you have. My experiences with different local wells here in Sweden say that.

Does your daughters’ freshwater aquaria take water from the household or your shop?
Yes her tanks are in the house and after the Kinetico water softener and Iron filter.

Do not take this question as an insult (I have personally done more idiotical things than this) - you have not - by mistake - take your aquarium water from the waste drain of the RODI filter?
Not an insult at all, I also have experience with things like this.
That said yes I am collecting water from the output of the RO/DI.
I have a 3 input TDS meter,
Sensor 1 located between the RO and DI stages and reads 80-150 and drops to 5 after the bypass rinse.
Sensor 2 is between the Cation and Anion stages, and reads from 0 - 45. (Was told by BRS this is normal)
Sensor 3 is on the output side and is always 0
My RO/DI unit is set up as follows.
Source water into:
Particulate filter to
5 micron Carbon canister
to
1 micron Carbon canister to
RO membrane 1 to
RO membrane 2 to
Cation canister to
Anion canister to
Mixed bed canister to
Storage container.
Containers are NSF containers.


By the way - your Hanna checker can´t read this low concentration of iron - Hanna themselves say
  • Accuracy ±0.04 mg/L (ppm)
Triton result 12 ppt is the same as 0.012 ppm - well below the accuracy - trust TRITON
Will do

Do a iron test direct from the well - before your RODI equipment. If reading anything - do a test both from the waste and clean water from the RODI unit. Take a test from your tap in your household too - after all treatment equipment.
I will have to order more Iron reagent packets as I only have one left.

Sincerely Lasse

RO-DI station.jpg
 
I missed that. Now I´m convinced that it most be a problem with your RODI because the TRITON test shows figures of different compounds that you can expect from a well where your household have the water cleaning equipment you have. My experiences with different local wells here in Sweden say that.

Does your daughters’ freshwater aquaria take water from the household or your shop?
Yes her tanks are in the house and after the Kinetico water softener and Iron filter.

Do not take this question as an insult (I have personally done more idiotical things than this) - you have not - by mistake - take your aquarium water from the waste drain of the RODI filter?
Not an insult at all, I also have experience with things like this.
That said yes I am collecting water from the output of the RO/DI.
I have a 3 input TDS meter,
Sensor 1 located between the RO and DI stages and reads 80-150 and drops to 5 after the bypass rinse.
Sensor 2 is between the Cation and Anion stages, and reads from 0 - 45. (Was told by BRS this is normal)
Sensor 3 is on the output side and is always 0
My RO/DI unit is set up as follows.
Source water into:
Particulate filter to
5 micron Carbon canister to
1 micron Carbon canister to
RO membrane 1 to
RO membrane 2 to
Cation canister to
Anion canister to
Mixed bed canister to
Storage container.
Containers are NSF containers.


By the way - your Hanna checker can´t read this low concentration of iron - Hanna themselves say
  • Accuracy ±0.04 mg/L (ppm)
Triton result 12 ppt is the same as 0.012 ppm - well below the accuracy - trust TRITON
Will do

Do a iron test direct from the well - before your RODI equipment. If reading anything - do a test both from the waste and clean water from the RODI unit. Take a test from your tap in your household too - after all treatment equipment.
I will have to order more Iron reagent packets as I only have one left.

Sincerely Lasse
 
Last edited:
Ok so with my last Iron test packet I checked the source water for Iron.
It read 0
Source water test.jpg


Reagent.jpg
Not expired.

So 0+0 equals 0 according to my tests with the Hanna.
Looked and looked so nothing states that the Hanna Iron test can be used for both FW and SW.

I am not doubting Triton just showing the results from the tests I can do.
 

IF YOU HAD TO TAKE A REEFING EXAM, WOULD YOU PASS?

  • Yes!

    Votes: 32 45.7%
  • Not yet, but I have one that I want to buy in mind!

    Votes: 9 12.9%
  • No.

    Votes: 26 37.1%
  • Other (please explain).

    Votes: 3 4.3%
Back
Top