How would you feel if I tore it all down?

Rev we need a full tank shot front on for sure

these huge tanks slowly swing one direction or the other for sure...takes time to either get really good or really bad but given this much effort so far, your tank is among the most important dino testbeds out there due to veracity of the strain. even if it staves off your legit reefing a few more months, not mixing approaches but carefully and thoroughly applying (with upgraded levels this time clearly) next steps on each of those methods above, until something gives, would be ideal. Then we can learn about swing vote actions possibly. I think it shouldn't be taken down until the dinos are beaten and then sustained for a good while without any corrective measures in place, to check for growback

when it is started over, a thorough sanitizing + hardcore quarantine on the new stuff should cover it. Id also like to see your UV specs, did you use a pond sterilizer or an aquarium sterilizer?

Fish as dino vectors (on slime coats) hasn't been well documented yet and its surely an issue, we've seen macro pics of it actually occurring in some dino threads. I figure if you are QT above and some still gets through, itd have to be through a mechanism like that where maybe they didn't slough and replace matrix layers well enough during the prophylaxis run.

Im interested to see if you have a sandbed or a partial one, that's first refuge to go as you press on. Its an unhelpful set of places to hide in the real challenge dino tank, in my opinion. we should be working on bare bottom setup only once at this concern level/
 
Last edited:
Dinos have pushed me to the edge of jumping. Yes it’s confirmed Dinos, I’ve added UV, conducted a blackout, driven my nitrates and phosphates up, dosed peroxide, added miracle mud and still losing for almost 10 months now and losing bad! Not a little bit of dino but a ton!

Ah, that's so sad to hear. :(

Hopefully we can pull you through.
 
I'm not going to voice my opinions on the dino infection... You've already heard from many that have far more experience fighting dinos than I have.

I will expound on the original question...

I once belonged to a group in Kansas City called the 'Fishheads'... (don't ask). We broke away from another KC area group after some difficulties, and over the next few years, completely surpassed the earlier organization. Ran great for nearly a decade, when I, along with the benefactor that was actually hosting the web site, and several other key members backed away from the hobby. Fishheads tanked, and I learned a valuable lesson. The key members MUST stay involved, or the forum will die. Yes, there are other 'key' members here... some of them even answering this thread, but inarguably, you are one of those keys.

R2R is a valuable forum, full of insight and encouragement, blissfully free of much of the pessimism and rancor many such online repositories are known for. If you're closing down the tank with the intention of starting it over, or downsizing, or whatever path you might choose that DOES NOT include your exiting the hobby... well, you do what you need to do. If shutting it down so that you can regroup and start over seems to be your best path forward, well, that's what you should do.

If, on the other hand, you see yourself backing away from the hobby entirely, that would be a path I would strenuously discourage you from choosing. You're important to keeping this forum on it's current path, and I'm not certain it could continue without you.
 
It's A New Adventure and a new build! might be exciting to start anew, anything you want to do differently? New processes or technology. One of the most enjoyable parts is the build and I think your R2R has proven that.
 
I dont know if matters,,my No3 is always above 20..
as of recently i drove No3 below 10 and Cyano came right back,,as of me dosing Urea in place of Pott. Nitrate to drive No3 up again for say,,my cyano is disappearing ..
Everytime my No3 is below 10,,I have other issues like this,,so No3 will stay at 20 or more..
I also bacteria dose too ,weekly at half dose to keep the bacteria in check or just to pacify my mind but things seem more consistent when i dose a weekly shot of Stability..
Just some more ideas to fuel your mental process.
 
Last edited:
Hang in there Rev. This hobby can be very frustrating.

If you do bail on the hobby let me know and I'd love to buy the site! :D
 
HAHAHA! NEVER leaving the hobby. Just frustrated with the current big tank! NEVER leaving R2R either so thank you for the kind words.
 
I'm not a big believer of tearing a tank down and starting anew (re-enforced by my recent experience with benthic diatoms.) Perhaps add algae to out-compete? Allelopathy is underestimated!
That.


Fuji mud not miracle mud. Or call Garf. And yea, it’ll only happen slowly.
 
This is what I have.

10D8836E-91CE-4598-B1B9-DF715C3F3ABD.jpeg




Probably...LOL! Nah it was just getting started when you got there.



Thanks for the info. My salinity is good though. :(



See the above photos and I am running a 55w sterilizer.

9D184D65-81A2-4D00-B56C-E91EEEF8ADE8.jpeg


B15F3102-67A8-4452-AFC5-93EA290AB8D0.jpeg

Those slides definitely may be chrysophytes. Is the algae at macro view more hairy then snotty? ( I know very scientific [emoji23]). I would give an Algaecide a try like api algaefix. Just be prepared as it will cause a nutrient bomb in your tank.
 
Dear Rev...

After such time fighting dinos and not enjoying the hobby if I was on your shoes I definitely throw all the sand and rock to the trash, rubbed pretty well the tank and start a new tank.
With time it happens to everyone and sometimes it’s the best way to proceed.

Here we have a saying that says something like this:
It’s best one foot on the brake that 2 on the coffin...

As per my reef it was spectacular but now several acros are going white!!!

Rgds
AR
 
I'm guessing there are many different strains of dinos; they seem so common in this hobby that the idea of tearing them down and starting over when you get them is border line insane! Can you post a picture so we can see how bad it is? I have dinos (I think) i'll be god danged if im going to tear down my tank...I just bought another $900 in sps frags.
 
I had horrible dinos, tried everything. In the end I tore down the tank ditched all LR, sand, etc, scrubbed the entire system and all equipment and started over with new lr and sand. At that point dinos had killed all of my coral and I only had a few fish so I was able to get by till the tank cycled again. Granted I only had a 40 gallon, so that might be a lot more realistic to do than a 400 gallon. My tank has been smooth sailing ever since. Good luck I definitely know the struggle.
 
I had horrible dinos, tried everything. In the end I tore down the tank ditched all LR, sand, etc, scrubbed the entire system and all equipment and started over with new lr and sand. At that point dinos had killed all of my coral and I only had a few fish so I was able to get by till the tank cycled again. Granted I only had a 40 gallon, so that might be a lot more realistic to do than a 400 gallon. My tank has been smooth sailing ever since. Good luck I definitely know the struggle.

Sorry, this is just not a solution. Are you going to start over again the next time you get dinos? They are too common in the hobby to keep running away from. Starting over a 400g tank when it gets dinos is not feasible. You're literally talking thousands upon thousands of dollars...I would compare it to trading in a car when the seats get dirty.
 
Hang in there Rev! Keep fighting the good fight. Winning that fight is the best feeling in the world. It'll be worth it in the end. Good luck! :)
 
if I was on your shoes I definitely throw all the sand and rock to the trash, rubbed pretty well the tank and start a new tank.

I've done it. 'bout '98, had C. Racemosa go asexual in my refugeum, weeks later, I had green grapes sprouting from every rock in the tank.

I ended up using 100 lbs of live rock I'd spent $5 a pound on to fill a hole in my back yard.
 
Hey Rev.... I feel your pain...except on a slightly smaller tank size scale. I fought those flipping dinos for what seemed like an eternity. The only way I found to beat them is to just go dirty. Stop dosing stuff... Stop chasing miracle cures.... get cyano and other algae growing.... and introduce pods. IF you tear it down and start new.... you may just end up with them all over again.

I am a firm believer that dinos exist in all of our tanks in some form. I know.... let the arguments begin.... The only difference is that they have competition from other micro fauna.

For me, I tried everything.... I have participated in many of the threads here and elsewhere. Yes... I even did some things that should have landed me in reefing jail!!!! What worked for me, I let my 225 TWV just go dirty. I stopped dosing EVERYTHING. I stopped doing water changes. I stopped doing blackouts. I basically put the tank on "neglect" mode and then let nature take over. IF your corals have been removed and fragged... If your fish are ok.... Then let the tank go. Heck... find someone with some nasty cyano and inoculate the tank. Throw in some hair algae... Add in PODs... Add Phyto.... What does it hurt at this point? If the tank gets ugly... let it. You will find that Dinos don't compete real well with other micro fauna, algae and bacteria. IT took my tank a few weeks... but the corner was turned. I would pull samples to put under the microscope. I could see all sorts of other micro fauna growing and taking over. I could see the dino population start to decrease....and ultimately go away.

Give it a try before you tear the tank down and start new. For me, I turned my attention to another tank. I was able to distract myself and my frustrations long enough to have nature take over. It worked. I am now.... dino free.... as far as I can tell. No Dinos to be found in my tank, but I am sure they are there. I cant find any in samples that I put under the microscope. I keep my nitrates at 10ish... and phosphates around .05.... of course with the errors of the testing methods. I feed my fish like crazy. I don't dose anything other than Alk, Cal, Acro Power and some .... operative term... some trace elements. My tank, corals, fish and inverts are doing great.

If after a few weeks things don't improve... Tear it down. Though, it would be interesting for a lot of people here if you were to follow this suggestion... if you beat the flipping things. They are a scourge for this hobby. That said, I think often time we make them more successful by keeping ULN systems and strive to see no algae and other bacteria in our tanks. We chase marketing. We chase miracle cures... In the end, we end up killing off other micro fauna, algae and bacteria that just gives the dinos more of a foothold. Give it a try. What do you have to lose other than a few more weeks.

I wish you luck. It is no fun.
 

IF YOU HAD TO TAKE A REEFING EXAM, WOULD YOU PASS?

  • Yes!

    Votes: 30 44.8%
  • Not yet, but I have one that I want to buy in mind!

    Votes: 9 13.4%
  • No.

    Votes: 25 37.3%
  • Other (please explain).

    Votes: 3 4.5%
Back
Top