How would you feel if I tore it all down?

Yes I’m whining but I sure do need some encouragement!

How would you as members here feel if I tore down my 400g basement tank? I’m seriously close. Lol!

Dinos have pushed me to the edge of jumping. Yes it’s confirmed Dinos, I’ve added UV, conducted a blackout, driven my nitrates and phosphates up, dosed peroxide, added miracle mud and still losing for almost 10 months now and losing bad! Not a little bit of dino but a ton!

All the corals have been in a frag tank that’s plumbed to the main system and they are growing very well. Just can’t put anything in tbe main tank.

I am seriously considering tearing it all down and I know that’s not the right attitude but I’m tired of throwing money and time at a box of uncurabke algae. Very bad for a saltwater aquarium site to say that but I just need to be real.

:(

Rev I feel your pain. I am going thru the same thing. I have tried blackouts, Peroxide and now I am using vibrant. I was thinking of doing the exact same thing but what is keeping me is Joe the R2R Reef of the month. in his final though he said "For anyone starting out or just plain struggling with your tank, hang in there. The solution is out there; you just haven't found it yet" This is what gives me hope. I have brown crap on my rocks looks like it goes away then comes back. hang in there The solution is out there WE just have not found it yet.
if we can transplant a heart successfully then we can defeat dinos in our tank.
 
Sorry, this is just not a solution. Are you going to start over again the next time you get dinos? They are too common in the hobby to keep running away from. Starting over a 400g tank when it gets dinos is not feasible. You're literally talking thousands upon thousands of dollars...I would compare it to trading in a car when the seats get dirty.
It is what ended up working for me. I did it at the same time I moved houses so I was breaking the tank down anyway for that, and honestly for my smallish tank it wasn't a huge expense. I could have saved a lot of money if I had bit the bullet and done it sooner that's for sure.
 
It has hair algae. But funny thing when I blacked out the display I didn’t Black it out, forgot, and the Dinos accumulated in the frag tank and the display was almost dino free!

If this is true and "most of the display tank was empty" Could it be possible to do this again, isolate all the dinos as possible and wipe just this section with a hard clean. Get rid of the vast majority of the problem and maybe the remainder after the blackout might be more manageable with some of the steps you've already taken

EDIT: Granted that would require relocating all the frags temporarily.
 
Yes I’m whining but I sure do need some encouragement!

How would you as members here feel if I tore down my 400g basement tank? I’m seriously close. Lol!

Dinos have pushed me to the edge of jumping. Yes it’s confirmed Dinos, I’ve added UV, conducted a blackout, driven my nitrates and phosphates up, dosed peroxide, added miracle mud and still losing for almost 10 months now and losing bad! Not a little bit of dino but a ton!

All the corals have been in a frag tank that’s plumbed to the main system and they are growing very well. Just can’t put anything in tbe main tank.

I am seriously considering tearing it all down and I know that’s not the right attitude but I’m tired of throwing money and time at a box of uncurabke algae. Very bad for a saltwater aquarium site to say that but I just need to be real.

:(

Can you post a tank shot?
 
IME, the key to beating dinos is to maintain water quality parameters that favor coral and macroalgae growth. I run a high nutrient system with a lot of light. My sps colonies start looking unhappy if NO3 drops below 10 ppm and PO4 below .1. Recently, I carelessly let my Ca and Mg get really low (320 and about 900, respectively). At the same time, I was trying to wean my sps off the high nutrients a bit as my clean up crew was getting slightly overwhelmed by hair algae. The result was dinos and greater hair algae growth, because the water quality favored those species. Personally, I think that dinos do just fine with high nutrient levels; however, coral and macroalgae do better under those conditions and out-compete them. And dinos really thrive under low nutrient conditions, where coral and macroalgae are struggling to survive.

I solved my problem in about a week by upping my Ca and Mg, and upping my nutrients to their previous level. As for the hair algae problem, my foxface (whom I would do well to name Blimpy and who refuses to eat any tank alage) is no longer getting nori on a clip. Hair algae is disappearing quickly now, lol.
 
I don't believe we beat dino's. I believe we establish conditions for other life to thrive which deprives the dino's of the nutrients they need.

You have a large tank. That is a double edged sword. The same benefits you gain with stability now hurt you. A small ATS will help a 35g tank but do nothing for a 400g system. And you have what, 600+ gallons? It means everything you do to out compete will take longer to grow large enough to help. Keep that in mind.



Competition:
You have added Fiji Mud. Great plan! Let that bacteria multiply!
Do you have much in the way of soft coral in your system? If not, see if you can add some! Have you wondered why you only saw dino's in your frag tank when you did your dark out?
How is your pod population? Are you growing Macro algae? Are you skimming effectively?

Deprivation:
More stuff to consider... if you are dosing nitrates and phosphates, make sure they are an inorganic variety.
Make sure you are not carbon dosing anything.
Don't add anything to your tank with amino acids or vitamins.
Keep up with manual removal. When you remove them you are also removing the nutrients in the exact ratio they need to thrive.

Reduction, reef safe:
IMO these steps can be helpful but are the least important long term. If you kill some of them without killing them all and you don't remove the dead organisms they decay and release the nutrients back into the system. If you have enough stuff competing with the dino's for these released nutrients then these methods can be effective. The more competition in your tank and the better the nutrient export, the better these will work long term. If you kill half of them and they just sit in the water they become food for the next generation of dino's.

H2O2 at 1ml/10g 2 times per day
Vibrant at 1ml/10g 1 time per week
Lights out (my least favorite)
Running UV with very low flow

Anyway, these are the dino' fighting thoughts of a noob reefer who should probably stick with giving electrical advice.

Oh, and any time anyone is fighting dino's, run GAC!!!!!
 
Hey Rev,
There has been a ton of good advice thrown to you in this thread. I did the Metroplex thing, it works but keep this in mind, Metroplex will not kill the Dinos, it will only slow down the reproduction. You still need something to outcompete them, ie. chaeto, hair algae and something to comsume them, ie. Micro Fauna, Pods and bacteria strains. I am currently trying to up my pod population and bacteria strains. I am dosing Microbacter 7 to up the bacteria, adding pods and growing chaeto in a refugium and a reactor. I am noticing the dinos slowing down a bit but they are not gone. Under the microscope they are not moving at all so that tell me something is working. I have a 200 total gallon system so it's taking a while. Other products you can use are Dr. Tim's One & Only, Dr. Tim's Refresh and Waste away, Zeovit Bio-mate. All of these products are a form of using Bacteria strains to clean your tank.
I totally understand if you want to tear it down because they are a PIT@ but just think back to the amount of time, effort and money you put into this tank. Make sure you can say you have done everything possible to get rid of them before you tear it down.

Good luck brother and please when you find a cure, let me know...lol
 
If you give up now Rev you'll never learn how to combat this and you can be sure that even if you start over they'll be right back. This hobby can be quite disheartening at times.
 
Yes I’m whining but I sure do need some encouragement!

How would you as members here feel if I tore down my 400g basement tank? I’m seriously close. Lol!

Dinos have pushed me to the edge of jumping. Yes it’s confirmed Dinos, I’ve added UV, conducted a blackout, driven my nitrates and phosphates up, dosed peroxide, added miracle mud and still losing for almost 10 months now and losing bad! Not a little bit of dino but a ton!

All the corals have been in a frag tank that’s plumbed to the main system and they are growing very well. Just can’t put anything in tbe main tank.

I am seriously considering tearing it all down and I know that’s not the right attitude but I’m tired of throwing money and time at a box of uncurabke algae. Very bad for a saltwater aquarium site to say that but I just need to be real.

:(
I had a similar issue with my 75g. From April to November. I found a solution by accident in part. My No3 has been Oppm and PO4 .15ppm . I dosed my tank with a Solution of Sodium Nitrate at .8ppm concentration level. once every other day.( started Nov. 2017) Over time Dino's disappeared, Hair algae lost it's hold due to this and my clean up crew and coraline started coming back. Bonus my corals color improved as well as their growth.( Further data upon request for NO3 solution formula)
 
I also had terrible algae with zero Po4/No3 Couldn't figure it out . Started dosing a "little" Things have really improved. The whole time I was thinking nutrient levels were too high. Go figure.
 
My Thoughts are if you know your frag tank is free , If the tanks are connected for sure separate them , Move everything out of the Main tank being its a 40 gallon tank Bleach everything ,Let it all become completely dry for a day or two Rinse it all out and rebuild the tank... If you had a much larger tank i would say keep fighting it , You can over come it but at what expense in time . The least time consuming on a 40 gallon tank would be Complete Reboot..

Be sure to NOT Cross contaminate anything from the two tanks for a few months Just in case you need to do the same to the Frag tank at a later date......

Good Luck
 
I don't believe we beat dino's. I believe we establish conditions for other life to thrive which deprives the dino's of the nutrients they need.

You have a large tank. That is a double edged sword. The same benefits you gain with stability now hurt you. A small ATS will help a 35g tank but do nothing for a 400g system. And you have what, 600+ gallons? It means everything you do to out compete will take longer to grow large enough to help. Keep that in mind.



Competition:
You have added Fiji Mud. Great plan! Let that bacteria multiply!
Do you have much in the way of soft coral in your system? If not, see if you can add some! Have you wondered why you only saw dino's in your frag tank when you did your dark out?
How is your pod population? Are you growing Macro algae? Are you skimming effectively?

Deprivation:
More stuff to consider... if you are dosing nitrates and phosphates, make sure they are an inorganic variety.
Make sure you are not carbon dosing anything.
Don't add anything to your tank with amino acids or vitamins.
Keep up with manual removal. When you remove them you are also removing the nutrients in the exact ratio they need to thrive.

Reduction, reef safe:
IMO these steps can be helpful but are the least important long term. If you kill some of them without killing them all and you don't remove the dead organisms they decay and release the nutrients back into the system. If you have enough stuff competing with the dino's for these released nutrients then these methods can be effective. The more competition in your tank and the better the nutrient export, the better these will work long term. If you kill half of them and they just sit in the water they become food for the next generation of dino's.

H2O2 at 1ml/10g 2 times per day
Vibrant at 1ml/10g 1 time per week
Lights out (my least favorite)
Running UV with very low flow

Anyway, these are the dino' fighting thoughts of a noob reefer who should probably stick with giving electrical advice.

Oh, and any time anyone is fighting dino's, run GAC!!!!!

Nice post! I am confused and trying to learn more from other's experiences...is it a true statement that higher nutrients help or is that not the case? I see you mentioned using vibrant but isn't that a form of carbon dosing? If you dose vibrant and lower nitrates doesn't that go against what you want with a dino outbreak? I read ALOT of information that says low nutrient systems are more of a breeding ground than higher; some folks mentioned they have issues when nitrates go below 10.
 
Nice post!
Thanks! I'll see if I can answer without turning this into a research paper. I will make a general disclaimer. There are thousands of types of dinoflagellates and they will all react differently. Even the fish disease, Marine Velvet, is a dinoflagellate. I wouldn't recommend the same advice for that strain! ;) So, I try to put out a lot of things you can try that should help for a majority of strains.

is it a true statement that higher nutrients help or is that not the case?
Two parts to this. When nutrients are balanced we normally grow more beneficial life, such as algae. Problematic stuff like dino's and cyano normally get a chance to take over when something is limited. I normally associate low NO3 with cyano and low PO4 with dino's. I recommend raising nutrients to make sure we aren't at a limit. The 2nd part is that not all nutrients are the same. Most dino's do better with organic nitrate than inorganic nitrate. Algae does just fine with inorganic nitrate so that is why I recommend it.

I see you mentioned using vibrant but isn't that a form of carbon dosing?
It has a tiny amount of carbon and amino acids in it but just to stabilize the bacteria. It is mostly bacteria dosing. The bacteria reproducing is what drives down the nitrates. For some reason (I'm not a Vibrant expert) it seems to stop after 3 days. It also seems to have something that directly attacks algae and may also impact the dino's directly.

If you dose vibrant and lower nitrates doesn't that go against what you want with a dino outbreak?
Since we are driving down all nitrates (organic and inorganic) using Vibrant, hopefully we are replacing them with just inorganic nitrates.

I read ALOT of information that says low nutrient systems are more of a breeding ground than higher; some folks mentioned they have issues when nitrates go below 10.
They are. I hit on it up above. Normally, algae will grow if they don't hit a limit of NO3 or PO4. When one or the other becomes limited it opens the doors to dinos and cyno. As an example, some common marine dino's have a N: P ratio of 45:1 or higher. They don't need much phosphate to thrive. Compare this to marine algae at closer to 17:1. And then there is cyanobacteria, with a common ratio of less than 5:1. So, for most common strains, cyano is associated with a nitrate limit and dino's hit with a phosphate limit.


Too much?
 
Last edited:
Thanks! I'll see if I can answer without turning this into a research paper. I will make a general disclaimer. There are thousands of types of dinoflagellates and they will all react differently. Even the fish disease, Marine Velvet, is a dinoflagellate. I wouldn't recommend the same advice for that strain! ;) So, I try to put out a lot of things you can try that should help for a majority of strains.

Two parts to this. When nutrients are balanced we normally grow more beneficial life, such as algae. Problematic stuff like dino's and cyano normally get a chance to take over when something is limited. I normally associate low NO3 with cyano and low PO4 with dino's. I recommend raising nutrients to make sure we aren't at a limit. The 2nd part is that not all nutrients are the same. Most dino's do better with organic nitrate than inorganic nitrate. Algae does just fine with inorganic nitrate so that is why I recommend it.

It has a tiny amount of carbon and amino acids in it but just to stabilize the bacteria. It is mostly bacteria dosing. The bacteria reproducing is what drives down the nitrates. For some reason (I'm not a Vibrant expert) it seems to stop after 3 days. It also seems to have something that directly attacks algae and may also impact the dino's directly.

Since we are driving down all nitrates (organic and inorganic) using Vibrant, hopefully we are replacing them with just inorganic nitrates.


They are. I hit on it up above. Normally, algae will grow if they don't hit a limit of NO3 or PO4. When one or the other becomes limited it opens the doors to dinos and cyno. As an example, some common marine dino's have a N:p ratio of 45:1 or higher. They don't need much phosphate to thrive. Compare this to marine algae at closer to 17:1. And then there is cyanobacteria, with a common ratio of less than 5:1. So, for most common strains, cyano is associated with a nitrate limit and dino's hit with a phosphate limit.


Too much?

Perfect! Thank you!
 
David have you tried carbon dosing? Something maybe like nopox?

I'd separate the frag tank and go heavy with nopox to see if that helps.
 
Took me 8-9 months. I introduced cynao on purpose, let it go unchecked for about a month. Dinos died off, treated cynao with chemiclean. Been about a month now and no dinos.
This is interesting. My tank was definitely ugly with some brown slime and other undesirable growth. Suddenly cyano took over. At first I tried to be patient and let it take it's course without aggressive measures. The corals continued to grow. However, cyano took over everywhere. Eventually, after about 6 weeks of conservative management, I used chemiclean. Now everything looks great.

My problem was not primarily dino's so it isn't apples to apples and it is valid to consider they may come roaring back after. However, if you can get cyano to take over and keep nutrients up over a few weeks, I imagine other beneficial bacteria may grow as well and may be able to outcompete dino's in a better environment once you have the treated the cyano. Chemiclean is an antibiotic but it may not affect some of the beneficial bacteria it seems.
 
Only you can answer that question. I think you give up more in the maturation of the tank than you gain from possible eradication of dinos though.
 
David you are at the same point everyone goes thru when facing tough issues with their aquarium. One can toss the tank and start over or Dig in and work thru the issues. It depends on the time you have to do the work needed to work thru the tank issues.
If one tosses the tank while you will get rid of the mess. You will be missing out on the learning on how to handle this type of issue in the future.
An aquarium is a learning experience the aquarium will teach you patience with both nature and yourself. While everyone has an idea what they would do it really is up to you and what you want out of the aquarium.
 
It sucks running into these situations, but I wouldn't restart. I think too many people restart once they get hit with dinos or other types of pests. There is a solution to your problem.

These dinos are living on something, the question is what?

Can you remove these nutrients completely without hurting other life in the tank?

If not, can you introduce competition and how much competition should you introduce?

I don't like using chemicals much if ever because too often they can disturb the delicate balance in the reef. But sometimes they are needed.

Maybe the best step to take right now is simplify the system. Take off the UV, carbon, gfo, etc. Reduce the amount of filtration you have. Run nothing for a week and see how the dinos respond. If they get worse, maybe start the skimmer up and run a week and observe. Do this with each piece of equipment until you see a decline. Then maybe match up equipment that has a small effect to possibly enhance the effect. Experiment and eventually you'll find a solution.

Don't look at this as a negative situation, but a chance to learn and have fun with it.
 

IF YOU HAD TO TAKE A REEFING EXAM, WOULD YOU PASS?

  • Yes!

    Votes: 30 44.8%
  • Not yet, but I have one that I want to buy in mind!

    Votes: 9 13.4%
  • No.

    Votes: 25 37.3%
  • Other (please explain).

    Votes: 3 4.5%
Back
Top