Inner Wokings- High Dollar LED Lights VS Low Cost ?

I can't say the difference on the internals but there is a difference. I know when I started out, I didn't want to spend hundreds on lighting when I had all the other up front expenses also. I started with a $200 dollar current USA fixture and the softies did awesome. But since that point ..adding LPS and then sps I had to add more lighting (obviously). Although I'm very happy with the physical look of the lighting in that tank, and coverage is better then the pods, coral growth just isn't the same as the high dollar stuff. Realizing this I started adding more (cheaper) lighting to the tank. I added a 220 dollar fluval. I didn't want to add too much so then I bought a waterproof lux meter. (70 bucks) because again, good par meters are also expensive. So still struggling I broke down and bought a 500 apogee par meter and was able to hit the right numbers.

Long story short keeping things alive and having difficult corals flourish are 2 different things. I should have bit the bullet and bought better up front. I spent the money in the long run, and lost some corals along the way because of it. I eventually quit nickel and dimeing money into that systems, and started other systems with T5. For half the money you can get more physical coverage, and the same.. if not better success for much less up front cost. The available bulbs now and the dimmable fixtures make them better choices than they used to be.. Don't give me wrong, I would love to have radions. If money was not an issue that's what I would have. If I were going to use LEDs it would either be Geeseman or eco-tech but I'm not spending $2000 on lighting for one tank either. That's my take anyway.
 
Bottom line, buy what you like and can afford, youll be happy with whatever you get led.

Im not sure you can just convert lux to par. Par is photosynthetic radation, that means mainly reds and blues. you could have 150,000 lux of red light, and high par, but that doesnt mean it contains the wavelengths that coral needs or adapted to. Most coral use blue light because red is filtered out pretty quick in the sea.

Id say having the abikity to adjust red, is a usuful feature, considering you could turn it off completely and halt algae growth. One thing a kessil cant do.

:)

All your points are well taken and I agree, you also mentioned that seneye was another topic I would like to read that thread sir, if you do not mind.
To be brief. Several of us who are working in lux/par have noticed an anomaly with the seneye.
A lux meter measures intensity. if you lux meter ONE t5 you get x lux & x par. if you meter TWO t5's you get xx lux & xx par. (sometimes XXy thus lux inaccuracy) this is why lux works though, intensity is fairly linear with par.
Ive spoken to several manufacturers right here on r2r and the science supports this.

So if you take a lux meter on the t5 and get x and use the apogee and D riddle conversion (40) for it you get x par. If you use a lux meter on led and use the Seney you get the conversion number of 30. and wind up with X par. so no matter the light(led mh t5) that has been tested w seney the conversion is always 30. resulting in significantly higher Par results than tests using apogees and others. this has been noted by several of us recently. It may be a consistent user error but it's VERY consistent so it raises a red flag for me.
Ill add that the seneye also gives color temp. My color temp meter has 3 sensors to do this. An apogee does NOT give you color temp. raising to me the question that, is the seney just estimating using a conversion number and a color meter, and NOT a single sensor scheme like a Li cor or Apogee true Par meter.
Nuff said on that. Perhaps another thread after I find on used;)


Bottom line, buy what you like and can afford, youll be happy with whatever you get led.
+1000000000 I cant stress this right here enough.
The only thing youll need to know is you peak intensity. thats the trick. Several folks making the switch to led had difficulty, this is due to Pur in the lights and PAR. you need a LOT more of led intensity compared to T5 and Metal halide.
 
I did a soldering job on a mars aqua for a local reefer where I live, I opened up the boards and replaced LED's that he specified to change out the color. changed the yellow "whites" out for 10k and 20k, 450 and 420 for the blues. Turned out really great and I'm sure its comparable light quality to other high end boxes.

Do you know where the replacement diodes came from?
 
My experience is that almost everyone will try to justify their purchases to others. No question that one can find justifications to buy almost anything. Having been in business and having sold both ends of the spectrum, my opinion is that most Chinese products cut corners anywhere they can. So I choose to buy reputable, brand name products because I can.
 
My experience is that almost everyone will try to justify their purchases to others. No question that one can find justifications to buy almost anything. Having been in business and having sold both ends of the spectrum, my opinion is that most Chinese products cut corners anywhere they can. So I choose to buy reputable, brand name products because I can.

Not to argue your point, but I have taken one of mine apart to see in side. Looks, I stress, looks very well made. Now as far as quality of the parts? How knows. We'll see.
 
Last time I opened a Mars aqua it had basically no heatsink. Is this still true for the newer stuff?
 
Photons are photons. So yes, regardless of how much a lights costs, it's putting out the same thing as a cheap ebay black box. Even the most expensive brands seem to cut corners on components like power supply, (non) water tight connectors, etc.

Higher price tags tend to get better mix of color spectrum, better controls, and good support.
 
Last time I opened a Mars aqua it had basically no heatsink. Is this still true for the newer stuff?
On my 300watt mars the heat sink is just a flat aluminum sheet. The chips are cheep enough if they burn out I can easily replace them.

Overall I am happy with the purchase. I eventually plan to mod them to work on a controller.
 
Kessils and metal halides have "shimmer." If your tank looks like it could fit into a pink floyd concert that's the "disco ball effect" :D
image.jpg
 
As an eBay Associate we earn from qualifying purchases.
Last time I opened a Mars aqua it had basically no heatsink. Is this still true for the newer stuff?
The LED chips are set on one large heat sink with thermal paste in between. The added fans above it help keep it cool.

Do you know where the replacement diodes came from?
I get diodes from ebay. Just search for '3 watt LED chip'. They typically come from China so expect 2-3 weeks for delivery. In the last two months I ordered some 385-395nm, 440nm-460nm, and 12k-15k. The warm white, green, cyan, and reds are usually for visual aesthetics.
 
So much to reply to but.....

How do we and the manufactures know,....what colors to use, what hue's, how many of each and at what strength ?

If there's many people running the LED's at only 25% (+/-) why do they make the lights go 100% ?
 
If there's many people running the LED's at only 25% (+/-) why do they make the lights go 100% ?

Different depth tanks, different distances from fixture to water surface, different lighting demands (softies to Maximas?). Having lots of lighting horsepower that you can dial *down* to what works best for your particular configuration will satisfy the largest target group. Having a light fixture that may be inadequate for the higher demand systems cuts out market share and gets a poor reputation "forget those lights, they don't have enough intensity to do....xyz" vs " those lights have more than enough power to do xyz".
Which ones would you buy?
 

IF YOU HAD TO TAKE A REEFING EXAM, WOULD YOU PASS?

  • Yes!

    Votes: 30 44.8%
  • Not yet, but I have one that I want to buy in mind!

    Votes: 9 13.4%
  • No.

    Votes: 25 37.3%
  • Other (please explain).

    Votes: 3 4.5%
Back
Top