Releasing Yellow Tangs into the wild....sigh....

Status
Not open for further replies.
Exactly Kev. Exactly. TREEHUGGERS who don't know how to read and "scientists with degrees" who are so blind to the facts....
 
aside from the whole "lets pour em out of a bag" 5 foot drop directly onto some rocks, If that didnt kill em, the shock of the params definitely wouldnt help...

just watching this lady drop those fish made me wanna reach into my screen and push her off the ledge lol although shes a little off the deep end if she thinks 9 of every 10 yellow tangs die.
 
thanks to people like this and other eco-nuts you can pretty much guarantee this hobby wont be around for much longer.
 
I knew nothing good was going to come out of this when they failed to pluralize "Tang" in the first seconds of the video.
 
i guarantee you these fish made it fine. chances are they were collected only a few days prior. the only reason we worry about water parameters is cause we have tanks that continuously change. we try to re-create the ocean everyday with lighting systems that have cloud cover, all kinds of gizmos and gadgets that money gets wasted on, and natural filtration, etc... theres a reason fish survive, adapt, and thrive...the ocean is perfect for them! yellow tangs are being collected at a ridiculous rate, rarely do i see nice size yellow tangs in stores..usually there the size of a 50 cent piece. meaning they dont even have a chance to grow! i believe strongly that for every 1 fish we see in the store a good handful dont make it. im pretty sure she did this to just make a point and doubt she does this weekly to cause a surge in demand. heres a link to some protesters in hawaii to help save yellow and kole tangs
PETCO targeted by protesters in Hawaii
 
i guarantee you these fish made it fine. chances are they were collected only a few days prior. the only reason we worry about water parameters is cause we have tanks that continuously change. we try to re-create the ocean everyday with lighting systems that have cloud cover, all kinds of gizmos and gadgets that money gets wasted on, and natural filtration, etc... theres a reason fish survive, adapt, and thrive...the ocean is perfect for them! yellow tangs are being collected at a ridiculous rate, rarely do i see nice size yellow tangs in stores..usually there the size of a 50 cent piece. meaning they dont even have a chance to grow! i believe strongly that for every 1 fish we see in the store a good handful dont make it. im pretty sure she did this to just make a point and doubt she does this weekly to cause a surge in demand. heres a link to some protesters in hawaii to help save yellow and kole tangs
PETCO targeted by protesters in Hawaii

If she bought those from Petco, they came from the mainland most likely so doubtful they were only collected a few days prior.
 
Well if this shop kept coral, inverts or fish from other parts of the world then she may just have released a new parasite or pathogen into the oceans around Hawaii. This could wipe out coral, fish or inverts and do far more damage than nay collecting could ever do. I would also assume this is illegal to release stuff back into the ocean.
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=W1YmwmRKXag&feature=share
 
wow what a nut!
first off was there any charges filed for releasing captive fish into the wild!! that is illegal and she should be prosecuted

not going to get into the whole tree huger debate. I hug trees to, a big bear hug after I cut it down when I move it

she complains about taking them then buys some from someone that took them?
is she going to make the 25' tall tank to bread the tangs? or is she going to keep buying them even though they could possibly be the same fish over and over
 
This whole thing started by snorkel Bob is getting out of hand and misinformation. What the reef hobby does not realize is there is ban in two counties in Hawaii that just passed and there is a proposal for the whole state. This would mean the loss of yellow tangs, golden dwarf eels, several wrasses and several other tangs completely from the hobby. This will cause an increase in prices of other fish. When there is a ban one place it spreads to others too.

Funny thing is since the collection of yellow tangs I guess yellow tang populations have increased.

Not only did she commit a crime on video, she is actually supporting the thing she is against by buying those fish.

Another problem is snorkel Bob runs a dive shop and scuba divers do more damage to the reefs than our hobby. If his lively hood was under fire maybe he would understand.

Adding economic value to a reef by scuba, fish collecting, fishing etc actually give people a reason to conserve the reef and opens awareness. Remove these and there is no reason to conserve.

Is there a need for conservation and regulations: yes
Is there a reason for out right ban: no but on individual species that are in danger..
 
Last edited:
She needs to take a big step back and analyze what she just did. Is this a real video or was she joking? There really can't be people that clueless. I am going to take this video as a gag, ripping on environmentalists. If I take her serious I will just say a bunch of mean, cruel, and disheartening things. I am all for preservation, but come on. You really want to make a stand? Then watch the movie "The Cove". That will get your blood boiling. We spend millions of dollars every year on searching for alternative life forms on other planets, yet continually kill the second most intelligent species on our own planet. Food for thought.
 
I am all for the environment and preserving the best we can. What she did is basically the same thing that caused the spread of lion fish in the ocean in non-native areas. She may have released a local fish, but the pathogens that fish could have picked up in the process of sitting at the store can do more harm than collecting a few tangs. Regulate the collection and monitor the population so they are sustainable. We have been doing this in mainland lakes and game fish for generations.

I have not been snorkling, but I do want to one day. I will say though I absolutely will not support Snorkle Bob and his battle against the aquarium trade. Incorrect facts and lobbying has gotten him pretty far. Just wait until someone in the aquarium trade is hurt by these regulations and decides to lobby against snorkling in the Hawaii area. What's he going to do then?

When emotion takes over in an argument, the facts are swept aside and only an argument is conveyed. Most of the time it is flawed as scientific facts get left out. If fact was the only thing being discussed at this point, people would be able to target a much larger issue and work to resolve that first.
 
Just agree that she's an idiot, and laugh it off.

All the bans that have been set forth have been in motion for a while. Not overnight. And the ones to set forth a ban on this hobby, are ignorant.

What about the ones who capture for food? Do they get slapped around? Or brushed aside?

TheRe just has NOT been a significant find on 100% captive breeding on ALL species.

I come from SE Texas. Where logging was started in the south. You won't go around any logging sites there at least, that hasn't been planted with new trees.

Genetically enhanced, mind you, but trees nonetheless.

So it's a matter of time before that 'way' moves to other areas of life.
 
Just agree that she's an idiot, and laugh it off.

I would not call her an Idiot as I don't know her and she is entitled to her opinions just as we are.
As for aquarists removing animals from the sea, I am not sure why we don't yet breed these things for the aquarium trade in the sea like we do oysters, shrimp, tuna and salmon.
I have been to 4 Hawaiian Islands and 4 South Pacific Islands along with most of the Caribbean and besides the well known "Tourist" places, there are thousands of un inhabited Islands and atolls especially in the South Pacific where fish and corals could be bred for the trade. I feel it would put more people to work than just the collectors and it would be practically free and sustainable. The un inhabited Islands are un inhabited because there is no fresh water on them. Many of them are not very far from inhabited places and areas could be screened in to keep out predators and raise fish and corals. I have always wanted to do this but you would need a government grant to get the Island.
In the past I was thinking about trying to get a grant to raise lobsters here in NY but unfortunately I had a real job and no time for that. I was even asked once to go to Greece to start an octopus farm. I explained to them that octopus lay eggs and die so it could not be sustainable very easily. They also only live maybe 2 years.
In the Caribbean I have seen many of the fish we keep caught for food. Angels, tangs, moray eels and lookdowns are routenly collected in traps and put on a beach for the locals to buy for food. Whatever does not sell is dumped back into the sea. I can't call those people Idiots because they have to eat and fish is what they have.
So if you have a spare Island and some time, go out and raise some fish. :bigsmile:
 
If she bought those from Petco, they came from the mainland most likely so doubtful they were only collected a few days prior.

they didnt come from petco. if you read the link, which im guessing you didnt.. petco in hawaii has put a stop sale on yellow tangs and kole tangs
 
they didnt come from petco. if you read the link, which im guessing you didnt.. petco in hawaii has put a stop sale on yellow tangs and kole tangs

That just happened. Chances are this video was made before petco's stop sale.

Did you notice that they block out the logo on the plastic shopping bag? Other than Petco, how many fish stores do you know of that print logos on their plastic shopping bags?
 
some food for thought:

According to DNLR/DAR findings both the Yellow Tang and Kole Tang population are up, even with the current collection practices here. Now if there were no collection, think about how many fish would be out there fighting and competing for food. How many would starve to death?

I wonder if that's a good or bad sign? I mean, tangs are algae eaters, and generally speaking, the worse the reef conditions, the more algae you find. Kind of like when they found that crown of thorns seastars were reproducing much more successfully due to the higher levels of algae in the water due to runoff and such. I'd be happier to hear the moorish idol and butterfly fish numbers were up too :D Just thinking out loud...
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

IF YOU HAD TO TAKE A REEFING EXAM, WOULD YOU PASS?

  • Yes!

    Votes: 30 44.8%
  • Not yet, but I have one that I want to buy in mind!

    Votes: 9 13.4%
  • No.

    Votes: 25 37.3%
  • Other (please explain).

    Votes: 3 4.5%
Back
Top