I would not call her an Idiot as I don't know her and she is entitled to her opinions just as we are.
As for aquarists removing animals from the sea, I am not sure why we don't yet breed these things for the aquarium trade in the sea like we do oysters, shrimp, tuna and salmon.
I have been to 4 Hawaiian Islands and 4 South Pacific Islands along with most of the Caribbean and besides the well known "Tourist" places, there are thousands of un inhabited Islands and atolls especially in the South Pacific where fish and corals could be bred for the trade. I feel it would put more people to work than just the collectors and it would be practically free and sustainable. The un inhabited Islands are un inhabited because there is no fresh water on them. Many of them are not very far from inhabited places and areas could be screened in to keep out predators and raise fish and corals. I have always wanted to do this but you would need a government grant to get the Island.
In the past I was thinking about trying to get a grant to raise lobsters here in NY but unfortunately I had a real job and no time for that. I was even asked once to go to Greece to start an octopus farm. I explained to them that octopus lay eggs and die so it could not be sustainable very easily. They also only live maybe 2 years.
In the Caribbean I have seen many of the fish we keep caught for food. Angels, tangs, moray eels and lookdowns are routenly collected in traps and put on a beach for the locals to buy for food. Whatever does not sell is dumped back into the sea. I can't call those people Idiots because they have to eat and fish is what they have.
So if you have a spare Island and some time, go out and raise some fish. :bigsmile:
Dang...and I just sold my spare island :tongue:



