The Ecotech pump clones have arrived in Ali Express !!!

  • Thread starter Thread starter Virus
  • Start date Start date
  • Tagged users None
what the heck difference does it make, ecotech is importing from China to build it

Screenshot_20240922_193031_Chrome.jpg
 
Last edited by a moderator:
I’m a fan of the MP series of pumps. A big fan. My problem with them is this - it’s old tech, they make exclusively, and we’ve been charged top dollar for it for 20 years. After all this time, you think they would be able to make it faster and cheaper and pass that on to us, which would result in more pumps sold as you allow more to afford them. Lower the cost and you increase the value, and widen your customer base

So many people wouldn’t even consider a MP40 or 10, due to the price. By keeping the price high, you invite competition, because some other company in another country says hey we can do that for less

If ecotech was selling mp40 for 200$ and another company determined they could sell them for 150-175, they probably wouldn’t even proceed with following through because at that price point people would just buy the original.

But if the mp40 is $470 and another company realizes hey we can make and sell this for $150-175…well that’s significant savings for a consumer and enough to sway them

By keeping the price high they are asking for this to happen

Not saying it’s right, wrong, or telling anyone what to buy. It’s just an observation and opinion
 
So many people wouldn’t even consider a MP40 or 10, due to the price. By keeping the price high, you invite competition, because some other company in another country says hey we can do that for less

What is a good price then?

MP10 380 USD
MP10 spare wet side 75 USD
MP40 470 USD
MP40 spare wet side 91 USD

Hobbyist spend this or more on a 1/4" frag or fish if truth be told.
 
I’m a fan of the MP series of pumps. A big fan. My problem with them is this - it’s old tech, they make exclusively, and we’ve been charged top dollar for it for 20 years. After all this time, you think they would be able to make it faster and cheaper and pass that on to us, which would result in more pumps sold as you allow more to afford them. Lower the cost and you increase the value, and widen your customer base
There is no economy of scale with these things. The are jobber size orders that have increased in materials and production cost steadily over those same decades, as has the cost of every other part of their business. The "faster and cheaper" has happened but not how you think. They have lowered quality in an attempt to maintain margin.

So many people wouldn’t even consider a MP40 or 10, due to the price. By keeping the price high, you invite competition, because some other company in another country says hey we can do that for less
And if you lower the price you lose margin or lose money. While there is some logic to premium pricing for premium products, I have a feeling most of these companies are struggling with margin in this economy. Regulations, wages, taxes, insurance, professional services, utilities, all costing a fortune compared to 5 or so years ago.

I think the vendor landscape is going to be wildly different in 12-18 months. Maybe I am wrong.
 
I’m a fan of the MP series of pumps. A big fan. My problem with them is this - it’s old tech, they make exclusively, and we’ve been charged top dollar for it for 20 years. After all this time, you think they would be able to make it faster and cheaper and pass that on to us, which would result in more pumps sold as you allow more to afford them. Lower the cost and you increase the value, and widen your customer base

So many people wouldn’t even consider a MP40 or 10, due to the price. By keeping the price high, you invite competition, because some other company in another country says hey we can do that for less

If ecotech was selling mp40 for 200$ and another company determined they could sell them for 150-175, they probably wouldn’t even proceed with following through because at that price point people would just buy the original.

But if the mp40 is $470 and another company realizes hey we can make and sell this for $150-175…well that’s significant savings for a consumer and enough to sway them

By keeping the price high they are asking for this to happen

Not saying it’s right, wrong, or telling anyone what to buy. It’s just an observation and opinion

The whole double edge patent sword

Ecotech has never had to innovate after first release because of competition. Their “changes” simply allowed them to extend the patent.

On topic, I find the suction cups a little odd. The magnets aren’t strong enough to couple them?
 
Are these made using the same design as the Ecotech but uses lower cost components, or components with a looser quality spec range? I could imagine that these could be equal or better than the Ecotech versions. The quality of some of these copycats have really gotten innovative.
 
Are these made using the same design as the Ecotech but uses lower cost components, or components with a looser quality spec range? I could imagine that these could be equal or better than the Ecotech versions. The quality of some of these copycats have really gotten innovative.
Sometimes it is the same factory, just different box... that is when it is blatantly bad, but you get a decent product. It may also be just different enough for them to lie with a straight face that they are not selling your product under a different name. These are typically good products.

Other cases, they are just reverse engineered knock offs, and in 99.999999% of the cases never an improvement, but rather a compromise. The item needs to be made cheaper or the reverse engineer does not fully understand the design he is copying.
 
I mean the real chances are all the parts for both eco and jecod come from the same factory. China just finally decided to create their own software to control it and release it. I had knock off neros and after some tinkering to get them to connect to my wifi they worked great. Having owned actual neros as well, I will say the user interface on the ai’s were so much more user friendly! Patent infringement aside, if these perform like the ecotechs then I’m game to owning a couple to add to the vortechs I currently own, especially if I can buy 3 for the price of a single vortech!!
 
That may not be ideal, but it does not make IP theft any more acceptable.
soon it will be a knock off of the knock off. It is a disposible world we live in
The Radion has been knocked off, and I dont know what else.

I like Tunze better than Ecotech, they knocked off Tunze too.

Best Buy brand Insignia, knock off

Ford is a Toyota knock off lol

How many Barbie knock offs do you see on a night out.

Generic drugs, knock off

I don't know, who's right, its just the way it is.
 
FWIW -

Best Buy's "brand" is manufactured for them by other major brands, they are not "knock offs", they are licensed products. In that same fashion Sears tools and appliances were all major brand OEMs sold under the "Kenmore" and "Craftsman" badges. No Stolen IP, but licensed or commissioned product lines.

Ford and Toyota? They have had very tight collaboration on products. They are not "Knock offs" or stolen IP.

Generic Drugs - can't be sold until the Patent for the original expires.

- The issue here is the theft of IP and patent infringement. The difference between who is "right" is pretty distinct in most cases.
 
What is a good price then?

MP10 380 USD
MP10 spare wet side 75 USD
MP40 470 USD
MP40 spare wet side 91 USD

Hobbyist spend this or more on a 1/4" frag or fish if truth be told.

IMO - it’s twice what it should be

A wet side is a magnet and plastic. There are no electronics or anything.

A full in mp40 has no justifiable reason to be 470$. It’s a great product but this is a 50$ controller, 20$ power supply, and then plastic, magnets, and a dc motor.

Jebao figured out how to clone and make their own from scratch for $150. Surely ecotech can make and Sell theirs for 200-250
 
IMO - it’s twice what it should be

A wet side is a magnet and plastic. There are no electronics or anything.

A full in mp40 has no justifiable reason to be 470$. It’s a great product but this is a 50$ controller, 20$ power supply, and then plastic, magnets, and a dc motor.

Jebao figured out how to clone and make their own from scratch for $150. Surely ecotech can make and Sell theirs for 200-250

Ecotech pays jobber type prices for a niche product. There is no economy of scale, other than what their China OEM passes to them. They pay United State taxes, utilities, wages, insurance, legal fees, property fees, bank fees and everything else under the sun.

Jebao is dumped out of a factory where economy of scale is spread over the hundreds (thousands) of products that they make and/or knock off and is one one form or anther an arm of the Chinese government. They don't have wages, insurance, legal fees, property fees, bank fees or any of that crap. So they sell a $150 product that the US company following the rule of law has to sell for $500 to keep their heads above water. They can also choose to lose money on the product simply to damage the US vendor selling the product, and eventually own the customers.

There is no way that Ecotech can sell those products for half the cost and stay in business.
 
IMO - it’s twice what it should be

A wet side is a magnet and plastic. There are no electronics or anything.

A full in mp40 has no justifiable reason to be 470$. It’s a great product but this is a 50$ controller, 20$ power supply, and then plastic, magnets, and a dc motor.

Jebao figured out how to clone and make their own from scratch for $150. Surely ecotech can make and Sell theirs for 200-250

About a decade ago someone actually broke down some part costs on Vortechs. If memory serves, the magnets alone in an MP60 were like $120 wholesale. And that’s when the MP60 was like $500 or so

I haven’t looked into recently but unless someone else is supplying rare earth magnets other than China, I doubt that cost has dropped significantly, if at all.

Back to my point above, the suction cups holding both sides is odd to me. I’m betting the magnets are super weak so they could lower costs
 

IF YOU HAD TO TAKE A REEFING EXAM, WOULD YOU PASS?

  • Yes!

    Votes: 30 44.8%
  • Not yet, but I have one that I want to buy in mind!

    Votes: 9 13.4%
  • No.

    Votes: 25 37.3%
  • Other (please explain).

    Votes: 3 4.5%
Back
Top