Inner Wokings- High Dollar LED Lights VS Low Cost ?

After reading this article by Dana Riddle, it's amazing how much you learn about leds. I see what he did there, with the whole lux to par conversion stuff. ;)
exactly. at that time he actually gave the conversion factor as 67 W/B @ 2:1. I DO think Led's have gotten better. Ive posted that article in lux debates several times.

I used a lux meter for initial set up, intending to "ramp up" from there. The more I got thinking about Dana Riddles' presentation, the more I wondered if I would see a colouration or growth change using the metrics he presented (flow, light, alk). While early yet, things look at least as good. Still slowly raising alk and lowering intensity.
Later tonite I will put a board on top of the tank to protect it, and take lux numbers at 10% intervals from 10% to 100%
its quite fun to experiment with. Its why I have zoas next to my best growing Acros. Xenia at the same level in the tank too. About 35,000 lux.

and at the same time, In some MH tanks the par is astronomical, and coloration is AMAZING too.

So in general Id rater have too much than too little available. And eyes shoudnt be trusted. as you turn the % dial 100 par goes up pretty fast. 6000 lux. I acclimate in increments of 3000 lux.
 
I have a reef breeder for 2 years now works great no problems and is on the cheaper side of leds I can't justify 1000 bucks for a light not in my budget and not too much different either
If u put a Mercedes symbol on a Volkswagen does that make worth more money
 
i read your first posts on sdr. its easy to see all your posts. Internet.
I personally metered the AP. saw that par data too. easy math.
I speak to AP users who have par meters, usuall after you leave the convo. THEY are quite helpful.
one of the mods is setting up a radion. with an apogee and a lux meter today. did the math
I believe your par meter is a lux meter that has been modified correct?
I can go on but its not worth it. I have been in lighting for 25 years. its not hard or complicated as you make it out to be.
You troll threads just to be negative and deride others choice of lights. thus their financial status.
You coined the term Blurple as a negative and as a slam against lights you dont like, you'll be happy to know its being used in good cheer to describe that color.

you never say anything nice.

Once again nothing but assumptions. You don't know me but yet have a lot to say about me whereas I have never made any assumptions about your character. Funny how I supposedly coined the term blurple yet it's been around for a long time and I was not the first one to use it. All I said about it was that to me it doesn't look good but to each their own. Just because I don't like it doesn't change the fact of what it looks like which is a mix of blue and purple, hence "blurple". Everyone is free to decide if they like blurple or not.

All this started because I did not agree with your statements about PAR and LUX but I guess disagreeing with you means I have nothing nice to say. I guess it's fall in line or get out with you. See that? Now I am making assumptions about your character.
 
Bottom line, buy what you like and can afford, youll be happy with whatever you get led.

But i wouldnt trade my kessil led for a mars aqua or china black box :D love the shimmer.

Im not sure you can just convert lux to par. Par is photosynthetic radation, that means mainly reds and blues. you could have 150,000 lux of red light, and high par, but that doesnt mean it contains the wavelengths that coral needs or adapted to. Most coral use blue light because red is filtered out pretty quick in the sea.

Id say having the abikity to adjust red, is a usuful feature, considering you could turn it off completely and halt algae growth. One thing a kessil cant do.

Corals dont need only light either they also eat zooplankton. So light is only part of the story. But if you want to grow algae, red light 660nm seems to work great. :)
 
What if i told you guys that China sells LED chips for very cheap and that changing LED colors is simple?
I agree. I live in North Borneo so I shop Alibaba a lot. Lots of competitive companies there. So you can price compare. Plus with 220 voltage standard here american electronics wont work
 
I went with the SB reeflights. mainly theres a guy I can talk to.
I absolutely love my sbreef lights, I have two of the 16" wifi version with 10 cycles that ramp up and down. Best money I have spent so far on my 90 gallon reef, did the research about them and the research of the LED's they put in them and why and theses lights are a game changer.
 
Yes! I think it does :D

IMG_1294.JPG


Oh boy!
 
I'm still curious about the original OP's question about parts. I'm just wondering how much of the high end U.S. light manufacturers use foreign made parts and just how much of them are universal across the market?

One note about my lights that I did like and learned about was if the diodes burn out, you can easily replace them cheaply (cents on the dollar) or just swap out the entire board for less than $70 with new diodes and lenses, sweet! Don't think you can do that with the high end lights?!
 
I love these debates. If you have cheap lights and they are working for you then they are great. If you have high end lights and they working for you they are also great. The part I like best is if either one breaks, don't deliver the results you are looking for then they are both a piece of junk. I did my home work and came up with something that I am happy with, Never looked back or wondered what the other guys are doing. Enjoy the hobby.
 
I have a Mars Aqua 300W. Whites on one channel, "blurple" (I love that word lol) on a 2nd channel. Each channel independently dimmable. Very very powerful lights, no need to run the blurple channel high to achieve high par.
On a standard 30 gallon, I am currently at 10% whites and 17% blurple at peak part of schedule.
I have the Mars Aqua on my frag tank and I run 30% blue and 10% white with the frags at 24" away. I keep sps in the center and have to keep palys in the corners to keep them open lol. I removed most of the lenses too to increase the light coverage
 
How is the color blending and disco ball effect with lights such as reef breeder that don't have a closely packed array of LEDs? I would think some of the bigger names like kessil would have the advantage here.
 
I might add that you always need to look at the spread and even distribution of light like the T5 and Halide fixtures. Also service/support/research sometime cost is high but development is not cheap. The leds seem to be focused under the lights and hot spots are not understood until you burn your investments. Using tools to understand light distribution is also expensive, but Vendors like Bulkreef help you with the studies that would cost more than the leader of the pack. One time you have a problem you will understand the hidden cost very quickly not only with support but a burned $300.00 group of frags. Just my $.02. I learned buying without looking at all the issues is costly, doing it right or not understanding the hidden costs is costly as well! This hobby is a new car some have better resale than others!
 
I might add that you always need to look at the spread and even distribution of light like the T5 and Halide fixtures. Also service/support/research sometime cost is high but development is not cheap. The leds seem to be focused under the lights and hot spots are not understood until you burn your investments.
How is the color blending and disco ball effect with lights such as reef breeder that don't have a closely packed array of LEDs? I would think some of the bigger names like kessil would have the advantage here.
its called "shimmer" now. ;) IMO it varies from light to light. Pulling the lenses actually lessens the effect. Phillips new light does this as well AND adds a diffusion to smooth the coverage even more. others are def adopting similar strategies. also taking advantage of the new studies about using LESS light overall. The geissman led t5 combos are a good example.
its pretty cool to watch the tech evolve.
and once years ago I got flamed for suggesting using a diffusion or gel on my reef lights. kinda funny really.
Using tools to understand light distribution is also expensive,
Thats why I now advocate the use of LUX meters. VERY VERY affordable. 100 years of development and use in lighting . A par meter in fact IS just a less sophisticated lux meter. A footcandle meter CAN also be used btw.
now I get flamed(and trolled) for that :D
 
you;re paying for the programming/scheduling, the blending of different light colors into a homogeneous daylight color (look at a cheap box you'll see what I mean, can see red and greens on rocks and sand), and the quality of workmanship/ post-sale support
 
All your points are well taken and I agree, you also mentioned that seneye was another topic I would like to read that thread sir, if you do not mind.
 
I use the mars aqua leds on my 120g. To be honest when I first got them I bought them as a cheap alternative until next year when I could afford some higher end LEDS but I really can't see me changing them. I don't really see anything in the units which are 3 or 4 times the price that is different enough to make me change them and spend a lot more money!
 
I use the mars aqua leds on my 120g. To be honest when I first got them I bought them as a cheap alternative until next year when I could afford some higher end LEDS but I really can't see me changing them. I don't really see anything in the units which are 3 or 4 times the price that is different enough to make me change them and spend a lot more money!

I did a soldering job on a mars aqua for a local reefer where I live, I opened up the boards and replaced LED's that he specified to change out the color. changed the yellow "whites" out for 10k and 20k, 450 and 420 for the blues. Turned out really great and I'm sure its comparable light quality to other high end boxes.
 

IF YOU HAD TO TAKE A REEFING EXAM, WOULD YOU PASS?

  • Yes!

    Votes: 30 44.8%
  • Not yet, but I have one that I want to buy in mind!

    Votes: 9 13.4%
  • No.

    Votes: 25 37.3%
  • Other (please explain).

    Votes: 3 4.5%
Back
Top