Releasing Yellow Tangs into the wild....sigh....

Status
Not open for further replies.
Yeah the comments have to be approved. I was sent a message explaining that my comment would not be posted because it was the stupidest thing they've read and that I obviously knew nothing about the reefs because it was way over my head.. Ha I said. Mmk
 
Sigh..

One more person that creates a "believe everything you hear" atmosphere for the masses.

Politics aside ;)
 
I had posted a comment shortly after Rev posted the video as well. While I didn't recieve a rude response, apparently my comment wasn't approved by the OP because it still isn't visible.
 
I say everyone makes a phone call or email. all the crap the aquatic community takes we need to give some back!!

http://hawaii.gov/dlnr/dar/contacts.html

I live in maine we have the hardest laws on wildlife there are. if I were to do this I would be in jail with $100grand in fines for each fish
 
Last edited:
While I don't agree with what this lady is doing, some of you really need to read the details, below the video.

These fish were never intermingled with any captive fish. The water they are in is the ocean water they were captured in. They never even made it into the pet store tanks.
 
You guys know we are not innocent either. There are things that can be done to not make us look not so selfish either. There are things that need to be done so there are fewer deaths in fish and coral all the way from the collector down to the end user.

It really does not look good when 1 out of 3 fish or coral make it into our tanks.

People complain about things like the tang police but honestly this kind of stuff is used against us. That pic of that yellow tang in like a 5 gallon tank? These people that are against this hobby do troll the forums looking for stuff like that to use against our hobby. People buy corals and fish that they can not keep even after they are told not too. All the crashed tanks, people keeping animals in two small of a tank, not doing water changes etc. is used against us in this hobby.

Some of the lfs stores I have seen are terrible, places like petco. I have a lfs not petco I just walked into and they have like 8 yellow tangs in like a 55 gallon tank and they are starving to death. This is unacceptable and should not be tolerated.

You know these people do get these bans in place because there are problems with this hobby. If there wasn’t they would never get this stuff to pass. All I am saying is this hobby could use some responsibility and some could start on the forums. Forums can be a good tool to get the message across.

I don’t believe in bans except for species that are endangered. But I agree there should be some management so we are not just raping the reefs or taking only the best corals.
 
This is their Facebook page, For the Fishes | Facebook I just posted on it. Please, if you do post, do so respectfully. Otherwise, it'll just further hurt the image of our hobby.
 
Wow, I can hardly believe this lady is serious! For every 1000 fish collected for the dinner table, 1000 die plus all the bycatch that gets thrown back dead after being netted.

I wonder how many of these nuts in Hawaii who are protesting tropical fish collection eat fish or other animal protein? Why is it okay to eat fish, but not okay to look at them and enjoy them in an aquarium?

Edit: just looked it up 28,376,038 pounds of commercial fish were collected in 2009 in Hawaii's waters.
 
Last edited:
I didnt see any posts other than what look like are from their camp. Did they remove your post? They look they are mainly focused on Petco right now, which is ironic because most responsible reef aquarists agree.

This is their Facebook page, For the Fishes | Facebook I just posted on it. Please, if you do post, do so respectfully. Otherwise, it'll just further hurt the image of our hobby.
 
Well, I posted something respectful, it will be interesting to see if it gets removed.
 
WOW... and my post has been removed. That is some pretty shady stuff.
 
Yes, I posted, they responded, then Liked their own comments, while a few others were Liking my comments. I kept it respectful, until I asked them why they felt the need to Like their own comments, creating a false sense of popularity with their very biased and somewhat incorrect comments. Then they deleted everything and blocked me.
 
10 likes, 83 dislikes on her video... I added another dislike.

Unable to see Facebook at work, but I will for sure check it out when I am done here.

It looks like this thread is linked to the video so all comments here can be seen through the link.
 
Yes, I posted, they responded, then Liked their own comments, while a few others were Liking my comments. I kept it respectful, until I asked them why they felt the need to Like their own comments, creating a false sense of popularity with their very biased and somewhat incorrect comments. Then they deleted everything and blocked me.

Imagine that.

Respectful huh?
 
Yes, as a matter of fact, my posts were very respectful.

I seen all your post, and your post were fine! I was the one who got a little rude! And they are VERY shady! I dont like them! AT ALL!
 
You'd think these people would be fussing over protecting the reefs rather than the collection of fish for our hobby. Wouldn't that make more sense?
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

IF YOU HAD TO TAKE A REEFING EXAM, WOULD YOU PASS?

  • Yes!

    Votes: 30 44.8%
  • Not yet, but I have one that I want to buy in mind!

    Votes: 9 13.4%
  • No.

    Votes: 25 37.3%
  • Other (please explain).

    Votes: 3 4.5%
Back
Top